Ask Holzman Round 11

[Holz]

Trade Pendles? No trade Pendles?

Im holding this week and coping a donut than droping him next week for boyd, unless i hear some good news.


I donlt like 2-6 weeks i held swanny and ablett and im not going to hold pendles. I dont think he is that good either you can afford not having him in your team, which you cant do with the other 2. If you can change him to a stanton this week you will be miles ahead of those who keep him.

[Holz]

Trade Pendles? No trade Pendles?

I've rage traded to Thomas.  :P

Trade Pendles? No trade Pendles?

I'm holding Pendles. Too many other problems to worry about :P

Thinking of making him Ablett. Will probably person out.

If it was a horrible injury they would have stretcered him off. It wasn't.
If it was a serious injury he wouldn't have been able to play out the half and would have been instantly vested. He wasn't.
If it was a medium level injury he wouldn't have been able to play so well in first the half. He did.

In short, it's a small injury. GET WELL SOON PENDLEBERRIES!!

*Yay for answering my own question :P

If you dont have ablett than its an easy choice i would do that trade in a heartbeat.

[Holz]

Holz, Morris & Redden Vs The Mullet Maric who scores more ?

morris has been bad of late but i think the 2 might just grab the win.

[Chopps]

Horsely > M Williams only or also use a 2nd trade for D Smith > Stanton?

i'd hold on stanton as he has a high BE unless you think he will Smash it then get him in

[Holz]

Horsely > M Williams only or also use a 2nd trade for D Smith > Stanton?

it depends if going smith to stanton will hurt you next week. If it just means you get one less donut this week and one more next week go ahead, stnaton could have a huge game this week. If it saves you a donut than definitely do it.

[Chopps]

Holz, Morris & Redden Vs The Mullet Maric who scores more ?

morris has been bad of late but i think the 2 might just grab the win.

cheers Holz

[essendon2]

I've gone

Pendlebury --> Ebert + 152k /Swan + 25k (got rid of him for Stanton in Round 9) /Watson + 80k


Horsley --> Williams
Treloar --> S.Johnson


sound good?  ???

horse to williams is fine if you think eh will play during the byes I personally wouldnt go stevie J he has been great but i would go beams, chappy,sidey over him. If you have all 3 and franklin than good trade.  I would probably pick up robinson for value. That is if you can get  a roudn 12 or 13 player.

got all of them already!!
but can you answer first question please!
it's either Ebert + 150k or Mitchell + 175k or Watson + 80k + a 0 next week

I'll get Swan as my last MID upgrade when he goes down in price!

[nickstiges]

Horsely > M Williams only or also use a 2nd trade for D Smith > Stanton?

it depends if going smith to stanton will hurt you next week. If it just means you get one less donut this week and one more next week go ahead, stnaton could have a huge game this week. If it saves you a donut than definitely do it.

Thinking on the Stanton trade, who would you prefer, Stanton or Watson or hold the trade for Swan's price to drop next week or R13?
(This would leave me with 8 trades)

[Holz]

thanks Holz but I can't afford to get Chappy, Robbo and Sexton... my options now are:

OPTION 1 ($19.5K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Mitchell (or Sloane maybe?)
Smith ---> Robinson

OPTION 2 ($10K left)
Horsley ---> Williams
Coniglio ---> Robinson
Smith ---> Chapman

OPTION 3 ($11.5K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Ebert
Porplyzia ---> Robinson

OPTION 4 ($148.3K left)
Coniglio ---> Sexton
Smith ---> Robinson

• Don't trade Horsley
  

OPTION 5 ($41K left)
Horsley ---> Sexton
Coniglio ---> Stanton

OPTION 6 ($252K left)
Option 5 + swap Smith to MIDs, Sexton to FWDs and trade Smith to Williams

• Upgrade Porps to Chappy or Stevie J after Rd 12

What would you do there?

Oh BTW, don't worry about bye structure, I'll take care of that, thanks Holz!

between 5 and 1 for me, i really like the stanton pick and i think he will have a huge game this week but have to go with option 1 mitchell and robinson look both great value and your getting in 2 premiums instead of 1 so i would go with that.

Mitchell would be my 6th premium mid, meaning I will have no Stanton, no Swan and no Watson unless injury strikes. Really wanted one of those three by the end of the year. Would it be better off getting option 2, as I'm still getting 2 premiums as well as leaving space for a 6th mid? You're a legend for this Holz

go with option 2 than in my opinion you will need swanny and ablett this season they look a class above the rest (sorry stanton). The time to get chappy is now he has a low BE and robinson is cheap too. Mitchell is good but I would rather him be swanny and you having essentially another mid in the forward line in chappy.

[Holz]

Horsely > M Williams only or also use a 2nd trade for D Smith > Stanton?

i'd hold on stanton as he has a high BE unless you think he will Smash it then get him in

Calvin has him at number 3 on his captain list, he only got 112 last time he played them but im pretty sure that was at the SCG, Stants loves etihad he has averaged around 150 from 4 games there. Im thinking he will either have a solid 100-120 score or he could go real big. It kind of depends if you value points or cash more.

[Holz]

I've gone

Pendlebury --> Ebert + 152k /Swan + 25k (got rid of him for Stanton in Round 9) /Watson + 80k


Horsley --> Williams
Treloar --> S.Johnson


sound good?  ???

horse to williams is fine if you think eh will play during the byes I personally wouldnt go stevie J he has been great but i would go beams, chappy,sidey over him. If you have all 3 and franklin than good trade.  I would probably pick up robinson for value. That is if you can get  a roudn 12 or 13 player.

got all of them already!!
but can you answer first question please!
it's either Ebert + 150k or Mitchell + 175k or Watson + 80k + a 0 next week

I'll get Swan as my last MID upgrade when he goes down in price!

go stevie J than, and wow thats a stong forward line. Im not a fan of ebert, I would go mitchell especially if watson gets you a donut. I wouldnt expect too much from mitchell but maybee around a 110 average for the rest of the year and thats enough for me to pick him as my 6th best mid.

[Tominator]

hang on what about this.... LAST POST I PROMISE!!

Two Options, both going to 2 premos and 1 rook.

OPTION 1
Horsley --> Williams
Coniglio --> Robinson
Smith --> Chapman

OPTION 2 (leaves me with $75K or $105K)
Horsley --> Sexton
Coniglio --> Mitchell
DUMP PENDLEBURY --> Swan or Stanton

[picker_man]

gday Holz just wondering what your thoughts on mackie are?? playing around with my team i can cut it down from 3 donuts to 1 this week if i go scotland to mackie and and horsley to ablett

cheers

[Holz]

Horsely > M Williams only or also use a 2nd trade for D Smith > Stanton?

it depends if going smith to stanton will hurt you next week. If it just means you get one less donut this week and one more next week go ahead, stnaton could have a huge game this week. If it saves you a donut than definitely do it.

Thinking on the Stanton trade, who would you prefer, Stanton or Watson or hold the trade for Swan's price to drop next week or R13?
(This would leave me with 8 trades)

I would wait for Swanny, Stants has the potential to kill it but we all know swan will. 

[Holz]

hang on what about this.... LAST POST I PROMISE!!

Two Options, both going to 2 premos and 1 rook.

OPTION 1
Horsley --> Williams
Coniglio --> Robinson
Smith --> Chapman

OPTION 2 (leaves me with $75K or $105K)
Horsley --> Sexton
Coniglio --> Mitchell
DUMP PENDLEBURY --> Swan or Stanton

Ok this is pretty simple I like both options if you go for league than option 1 is really good if you go for overall ranking bring in Swanny.