Ask Holzman Round 11

[Holz]

Got the option to trade either Jmac or Horsley and get a premium mid in.

Everyone seems to be selling Horsley which I can understand but in my case I'm thinking of holding on to him as:

a. He has scored tons b4 and could do so again when he comes back fit
b. Jmac might play another two games and get rested again when I might need him most
c. Horsley would have more JS than Jmac.....again, everyone says he's dropped but he's only "rested"
d. He could be my M7/8 with Zorko for the rest of the year.

Would you or anyone else agree with this assumption or say.......nah, you're crazy and sell the Horse.

Cheers mate

its really a judgement call but I think horse was dropped and they just said he was rested. his role has changed and i cant see him scoring any more tons. Jmac on the other hand when plays will score decently but as you said the risk is he is old so may be rested.

Your not crazy but I would sell horse.

[LF]

Redden or Stephenson on field?

Everyone is saying Redden, but someone brought up a good point Redden has never gone over 70, wheras the Big O has 3/5 70+ scores.  However Redden playing hawks probably wins it for me. Redden for Safety the Big O for possibly reward.

Just to add in I`m going with Orren because you know he is not the sub.

[jk17]

Hey,

SJ V Beams V Chappy V Robinson

Who would you bring in? Cheers  :)

[Dutchie64]

Thanks Holz...... ;)

Think I will stick with the Horse. Could be disastrous but hey.....could turn out alright.

That's the beauty of DT and why we enjoy it.

[Holz]

Hey,

SJ V Beams V Chappy V Robinson

Who would you bring in? Cheers  :)

thats a hard pick all really good beams is the best for me so i would go him unless the 60k you save from going Robinson is really usefull

[Holz]

Thanks Holz...... ;)

Think I will stick with the Horse. Could be disastrous but hey.....could turn out alright.

That's the beauty of DT and why we enjoy it.

whatever option you seem to go it always finds a way to come back and bite you

[Flame]

Hey Holz

Only copping 3 donuts this week Smedts, Horse and Couch. Should I trade Horse to Sexton for Cash or Couch to Sexton (Williams) or be thankful I only have 3 donuts and save my 12 trades left?

Cheers

[Dutchie64]

"

Thanks Holz...... ;)

Think I will stick with the Horse. Could be disastrous but hey.....could turn out alright.

That's the beauty of DT and why we enjoy it.

whatever option you seem to go it always finds a way to come back and bite you

Yep, that sounds about right for this years DT. Anyway, given you a cheer for the good work......keep it up!

[Zombie2.5]

Hey, interesting idea just popped into my head.
Should i trade Horsley>Swan?? Have plenty of cash to spare.

Reasoning is I'm still in the Eliminator and at this point, i think i am down one player. Plus i doubt Horsley will play next round anyways, so I actually save a donut. And even if he does play, he'll probably lose cash, and if i do it i get Swanny's extra score. Only problem is Swanny might drop a bit, $590k is quite a lot. (i have 450k cash, the trade costs $290k.

Is the trade worth it? Even if I'm not caring about the Eliminator, is it still worth it?
I did this quickly, so tell me if theres any mistakes in there.

[Holz]

Hey Holz

Only copping 3 donuts this week Smedts, Horse and Couch. Should I trade Horse to Sexton for Cash or Couch to Sexton (Williams) or be thankful I only have 3 donuts and save my 12 trades left?

Cheers

3 donuts is ok, i would still do couch to sexton becasue couch is looking like he wont play this year.

[Holz]

Hey, interesting idea just popped into my head.
Should i trade Horsley>Swan?? Have plenty of cash to spare.

Reasoning is I'm still in the Eliminator and at this point, i think i am down one player. Plus i doubt Horsley will play next round anyways, so I actually save a donut. And even if he does play, he'll probably lose cash, and if i do it i get Swanny's extra score. Only problem is Swanny might drop a bit, $590k is quite a lot. (i have 450k cash, the trade costs $290k.

Is the trade worth it? Even if I'm not caring about the Eliminator, is it still worth it?
I did this quickly, so tell me if theres any mistakes in there.

Yes definately worth it doesnt matter what a players BE is if they are a keeper. Could have a huge game this week.

[Flame]

Hey Holz

Only copping 3 donuts this week Smedts, Horse and Couch. Should I trade Horse to Sexton for Cash or Couch to Sexton (Williams) or be thankful I only have 3 donuts and save my 12 trades left?

Cheers

3 donuts is ok, i would still do couch to sexton becasue couch is looking like he wont play this year.

What about Williams Holz??

[Holz]

Hey Holz

Only copping 3 donuts this week Smedts, Horse and Couch. Should I trade Horse to Sexton for Cash or Couch to Sexton (Williams) or be thankful I only have 3 donuts and save my 12 trades left?

Cheers

3 donuts is ok, i would still do couch to sexton becasue couch is looking like he wont play this year.

What about Williams Holz??

I have less faith in him but he should play during the byes. I just dont like rookies from top teams.

[Zombie2.5]

Hey, interesting idea just popped into my head.
Should i trade Horsley>Swan?? Have plenty of cash to spare.

Reasoning is I'm still in the Eliminator and at this point, i think i am down one player. Plus i doubt Horsley will play next round anyways, so I actually save a donut. And even if he does play, he'll probably lose cash, and if i do it i get Swanny's extra score. Only problem is Swanny might drop a bit, $590k is quite a lot. (i have 450k cash, the trade costs $290k.

Is the trade worth it? Even if I'm not caring about the Eliminator, is it still worth it?
I did this quickly, so tell me if theres any mistakes in there.

Yes definately worth it doesnt matter what a players BE is if they are a keeper. Could have a huge game this week.

Thanks!! You're the best!! 8)

Didn't think of it before, but do you think Swanny will be a bit shaky coming back from a rest??

[pinochio]

feel like keeping horsely is the way to go....just a gut

pendles trading now my main tpoic of debate.....if i do watson or stanton???



thx matte!!