To trade Horsely?

[LaHug]

I know everyone's saying don't trade in round 11 because saving a donut now will just give you one in the next few rounds... but what if you want to trade someone who's playing this week to someone else playing?
Horsely has a large mountain for a tired rookie to climb just to reach his B/E this week and, after earning so much cash so quickly, you'd hate to see him lose it all again.
Is it worth upgrading or downgrading him to someone?
Does the same apply for other topped out rookies like Morris?
Your thoughts, people, I welcome them!

[Windigo]

I've rage traded and got back in GAJ for him.  :P

[Ricochet]

He WAS going to be going after RD 12 for Swan....
With a large BE this week that he will 1) not hit and drop in price or 2) hit and stay the same price
so by the time RD 13 comes around he will either be the same price or have dropped
I'm getting rid of him now

[Windigo]

Scrap that. Kreuzer out means I'm keeping him.  :(

[picker_man]

its a tough one huggy :-\ keep reverting back to trading pendles and horsley & bringing in ablett and swan which seems like 2 great trades if pendles is out for 4 and horsley is going to have a tough time reaching his b/e as you said, but it wasnt in my plans and keeping horsley to rd13 and then bringing in swan seems so much smarter.... but i dont think i could afford it then if horsley lose's any money ahhhhh 1st time im stumped on what to do :'(

[jabroni]

yeah i wouldnt trade this week but hes going next week for thompson

[LaHug]

My personal problem is that I can't afford to go Horsely to Swan in one (or even two) trades.
I have 5 premium mids already (Stanton, Ablett, Mitchell, Selwood, Rockliff) so I'd want to get Swan or Boyd as my last spot.
That means, unless I use three trades this week, I'd have to downgrade Horsely.
Is there anyone to whom downgrading would be a viable option?

[Jukes]

I upgraded him this week to Stevie J :D

Btw LaHug my captain will be up tommorow.

[LaHug]

I upgraded him this week to Stevie J :D

Btw LaHug my captain will be up tommorow.

Great job! I should probably get back to studying, considering I have an exam tomorrow... but I had one today and my brain is tired!

[-Hector-]

Sorry guys, I've just posted a new topic when it's already (sort of) covered in here.

I'm looking at Magner to player X and then Horsely to Gary before he rises in price again!

Any ideas on player X and who he should be?

[Dutchie64]

If he doesn't play this week-end and/or the next he won't drop in price but Thommo will drop hugely after rd12 and will pick him up in rd13 for the horse, that's my plan .....this all depends whether horse plays or not

[picker_man]

If he doesn't play this week-end and/or the next he won't drop in price but Thommo will drop hugely after rd12 and will pick him up in rd13 for the horse, that's my plan .....this all depends whether horse plays or not

if only i didnt have thomo, pendles, mitchell already i might follow suit but all the guys i want to bring in are set to rise not drop in price like the spuds i already have >:(

[Ricochet]

My personal problem is that I can't afford to go Horsely to Swan in one (or even two) trades.
I have 5 premium mids already (Stanton, Ablett, Mitchell, Selwood, Rockliff) so I'd want to get Swan or Boyd as my last spot.
That means, unless I use three trades this week, I'd have to downgrade Horsely.
Is there anyone to whom downgrading would be a viable option?

Who are your other rookies LH?

[Justin Bieber]

I have a feeling he may get dropped :(

So trade if so.

[Colliwobblers]

trade regardless this round or after round 11 or 12 guessing you'll have 2 round 13 premium mids by then or one plus sexton so horse out makes sense, for me it's after round 11 for Boyd unless dropped then i'll have to rethink...