Ask Q (1/6/12)

[Master Q]

You guys know how it work! Ask me a question and I will give you my honest opinion  :)

Deadline: 6:15 PM (I have my own team)  ;)

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

[Justin Bieber]

Ellis or Bugg to get the sack?

Byes are in consideration.

[nickstiges]

Who to put on the field for Heppell, Bugg or Darley?

[stew42]

Hey Q, should I put Mummy on the field? Not named as 1st ruck (although I'm not too worried about that). There would also be fairly short odds of him getting a vest, wouldn't there? My other rucks are Jacobs, Giles and Big O.

Also, who do you think will be subs for GCS? I have both Horsely (on field) and Hall (bench) in my team, and am interested what you think.

Finally, who to field, Sammy Shaw or Ellis?

Thanks a lot.

PS. The observant ones amongst you will note that I have already asked this question... never hurts for a second opinion!

[Andrew]

Devon Smith -> Sexton this week, or wait a week and get him in round 11 when you know he's named?

Forward line: Franklin, Robinson, Sidebottom, Beams, Martin, Stevie J, Treloar (SMITH, Cameron)

[Master Q]

Ellis or Bugg to get the sack?

Byes are in consideration.

Depends which one you will need more...

Who to put on the field for Heppell, Bugg or Darley?

Heppell ain't playing. I'd go Bugg.

[Alka]

Trade out D.Smith or Porplyzia?
I'll need the other through the bye rounds, so Porps is more likely to be playing? D.Smith has more money to be made though..

[Capper]

All GWS
Adams, Smith or Treloar?? Which 2 to start??

[Master Q]

Hey Q, should I put Mummy on the field? Not named as 1st ruck (although I'm not too worried about that). There would also be fairly short odds of him getting a vest, wouldn't there? My other rucks are Jacobs, Giles and Big O.

Also, who do you think will be subs for GCS? I have both Horsely (on field) and Hall (bench) in my team, and am interested what you think.

Finally, who to field, Sammy Shaw or Ellis?

Thanks a lot.

PS. The observant ones amongst you will note that I have already asked this question... never hurts for a second opinion!

Wow you still have Mummy  :o He's a premium so I guess you have to go with him over GIles. If not, you may as well trade him soon.

Sammy for me.

[Thorpy]

Backs: H.Scotland, G.Broughton, G.Birchall, B.Goddard, H.Shaw, T.Bugg, R.Hargrave < S.Darley, B.Smedts>

Midfield:  M.Boyd, T.Cotchin, J.Selwood, J.Redden, M.Robinson, K.Horsely < J.Magner, J, McDonald >
Rucks: , J.Giles, I.Maric <J.Redden, O.Stephenson>

Forwards: A.Treloar, L.Franklin, S.Sidebottom, M.Pavlich, D.Martin, D.Smith, D.Zorko <T.Couch ,A.Hall>

Thats my team and I have 198k in the kitty what do I do? or should I hold keeping in mind that I have to get rid of J mac this week or next week so my byes work perfectly Im think Macca to Pendles but yeh

[Master Q]

Devon Smith -> Sexton this week, or wait a week and get him in round 11 when you know he's named?

Forward line: Franklin, Robinson, Sidebottom, Beams, Martin, Stevie J, Treloar (SMITH, Cameron)

Next week IMHO.

Trade out D.Smith or Porplyzia?
I'll need the other through the bye rounds, so Porps is more likely to be playing? D.Smith has more money to be made though..

Smith...

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer ;)

[Master Q]

All GWS
Adams, Smith or Treloar?? Which 2 to start??

Tre and Adams.

Backs: H.Scotland, G.Broughton, G.Birchall, B.Goddard, H.Shaw, T.Bugg, R.Hargrave < S.Darley, B.Smedts>

Midfield:  M.Boyd, T.Cotchin, J.Selwood, J.Redden, M.Robinson, K.Horsely < J.Magner, J, McDonald >
Rucks: , J.Giles, I.Maric <J.Redden, O.Stephenson>

Forwards: A.Treloar, L.Franklin, S.Sidebottom, M.Pavlich, D.Martin, D.Smith, D.Zorko <T.Couch ,A.Hall>

Thats my team and I have 198k in the kitty what do I do? or should I hold keeping in mind that I have to get rid of J mac this week or next week so my byes work perfectly Im think Macca to Pendles but yeh

I like Mac to Pendles.

[nickstiges]

Who to put on the field for Heppell, Bugg or Darley?

Heppell ain't playing. I'd go Bugg.

That's why I said for Heppell, but cheers anyway, +1 for you :)

[Holz]

What do you think of jack grimes 92 average in his last 5 after a slow start. Is around 380k i could go enright for the same price or pay 35k extra for broughton.

[Master Q]

Who to put on the field for Heppell, Bugg or Darley?

Heppell ain't playing. I'd go Bugg.

That's why I said for Heppell, but cheers anyway, +1 for you :)

ah, misread  :-[

What do you think of jack grimes 92 average in his last 5 after a slow start. Is around 380k i could go enright for the same price or pay 35k extra for broughton.

Not for me I guess. I'd try and find that extra cash and get a clear premium.