Ask the coaches round 10

[Holz]

bit later than usual but ask away

[stew42]

Hey Holz, should I put Mummy on the field? Not named as 1st ruck (although I'm not too worried about that). There would also be fairly short odds of him getting a vest, wouldn't there? My other rucks are Jacobs, Giles and Big O.

Also, who do you think will be subs for GCS? I have both Horsely (on field) and Hall (bench) in my team, and am interested what you think.

Finally, who to field, Sammy Shaw or Ellis?

Thanks a lot :)

[Dave085]

Seriously help me have more confidence in putting Sidebottom as captain. I rarely, rarely put someone captain who is not in my mids. I have to C on him now, and have the VC on Ablett. He has scored pretty well against collingwood in the past and very well at the MCG in most games with the Gold Coast...

I know Sidey is in good form, but the previous stats on paper look better for Ablett....

[Justin Bieber]

Ellis or Bugg for the sack.

In for Darley.

[Holz]

Hey Holz, should I put Mummy on the field? Not named as 1st ruck (although I'm not too worried about that). There would also be fairly short odds of him getting a vest, wouldn't there? My other rucks are Jacobs, Giles and Big O.

Also, who do you think will be subs for GCS? I have both Horsely (on field) and Hall (bench) in my team, and am interested what you think.

Finally, who to field, Sammy Shaw or Ellis?

Thanks a lot :)

Im not saying it wont happen but teams dont normally bring back their stars to give them the green vest, if they are playing him he should play a full game so i would stick with him. If they do sub him i appoligise but it would be a stupid move on their behalf.

horse wont be the sub but hall is a decent chance, i wouldnt start him unless i had too.

richmond play tonigh if Ellis isnt the sub than play him.

[Holz]

Ellis or Bugg for the sack.

In for Darley.

simple as this, whatever helps you strucutre for the byes.

[Holz]

Seriously help me have more confidence in putting Sidebottom as captain. I rarely, rarely put someone captain who is not in my mids. I have to C on him now, and have the VC on Ablett. He has scored pretty well against collingwood in the past and very well at the MCG in most games with the Gold Coast...

I know Sidey is in good form, but the previous stats on paper look better for Ablett....

Im going to steal Calvins work from DT talk here

"Yes, I’m speaking of Steele Sidebottom and this is why he is my #1 pick for round 10. Firstly, after crunching the numbers I can not see one negative reason why he will not score well this week. His form has been amazing. He has had 135 and 139 in the last 2 weeks and goes for his 8th straight 100+ score this week and he plays at the MCG where he had 139 in his last game there. Over the last 7 rounds, Steele’s lowest score is just 109 and this week he plays the Suns! He had 94 on them last year but even Port scored well on them last week with Ebert topping the list with 124. From the Port list, 7 players scored 90+ showing that there are plenty of points up for grabs. Collingwood will dominate this game and there is no reason why the Man of Steele can not continue his ripping form with something big."

I for the last 2 years have always put the C on whoever Calvin rates the highest and is in my team, doing this I have got a 135 average from my captains this year. Saying that for the first time in 2 years im not going with Calvin and im locking in Pendles i would choose sidey over ablett though. GC suck so as long as you have a collingwood guy as your captain your all good.

[Capper]

Quick one

Would you start DSmith and Treloar over Adams (all GWS)???

[Dave085]

Ok, Ok, im'a doit. Please pray for a high score!

[Holz]

Quick one

Would you start DSmith and Treloar over Adams (all GWS)???

yes dont rate adams smith and trealor both guns.

[Flame]

Seriously help me have more confidence in putting Sidebottom as captain. I rarely, rarely put someone captain who is not in my mids. I have to C on him now, and have the VC on Ablett. He has scored pretty well against collingwood in the past and very well at the MCG in most games with the Gold Coast...

I know Sidey is in good form, but the previous stats on paper look better for Ablett....

Im going to steal Calvins work from DT talk here

"Yes, I’m speaking of Steele Sidebottom and this is why he is my #1 pick for round 10. Firstly, after crunching the numbers I can not see one negative reason why he will not score well this week. His form has been amazing. He has had 135 and 139 in the last 2 weeks and goes for his 8th straight 100+ score this week and he plays at the MCG where he had 139 in his last game there. Over the last 7 rounds, Steele’s lowest score is just 109 and this week he plays the Suns! He had 94 on them last year but even Port scored well on them last week with Ebert topping the list with 124. From the Port list, 7 players scored 90+ showing that there are plenty of points up for grabs. Collingwood will dominate this game and there is no reason why the Man of Steele can not continue his ripping form with something big."

I for the last 2 years have always put the C on whoever Calvin rates the highest and is in my team, doing this I have got a 135 average from my captains this year. Saying that for the first time in 2 years im not going with Calvin and im locking in Pendles i would choose sidey over ablett though. GC suck so as long as you have a collingwood guy as your captain your all good.

I'm going Frontbum!! Class player who bucks is playing on the ball ATM. Ablett is my Vice!

[jamesalex]

This is for SC sorry it's in the wrong section, but i'm desperate for an opinion!

Which combo would you rather:

Clarke and Hurn
OR
Bugg and Waters

Thanks!

[Holz]

This is for SC sorry it's in the wrong section, but i'm desperate for an opinion!

Which combo would you rather:

Clarke and Hurn
OR
Bugg and Waters

Thanks!

the option with waters is always the correct one, who cares if its SC or DT he is a gun

[Alka]

Trade D.Smith or Porplyzia?

[Holz]

Trade D.Smith or Porplyzia?

much of a muchness to me i would want both out at some stage, i would say trade out smith just becasue he isnt likely to get a pesky rest during the bye rounds.