Best defence upgrade?

[rider]

Leaning towards Scotland, but Waters last couple of weeks have been  :o WOW!

Don't worry about bye structure.

Def Line:

Lids, Goddud, Shaw, Broughton, HeppD, Hargrave, Waters/Scotland, (Darley, Smedts)

[rider]

bump.

pretty close, can anyone give some good reasons why one over the other, or are they just pretty evenly matched?

[nrich102]

id say scotland

[picker_man]

to late for waters when he's a similiar price to other premium backs that arnt as injury prone

scotland ;)

[The_Captain]

Defs scotland. More consistent, safer option, and he loves cheap possessions which is just lovely for dream team :)

[Windigo]

Scotland just. Waters has been killing it this year, but he is always a chance for an injury.

[Thunderstruck]

Scotland by a whisker...;)