Chappy is he worth an extra trade???

[disco1992]

Hey all, sorry about this post team thing but this is my current team
Delidio, Goddard, Waters, Broughton, Birchall, Malceski, Hargrave (Morris, Ellis)
Stanton, Boyd, Pendles, Mitchell, Horsley, Mcdonald (Shiel, D Smith)
Maric, Giles (Stephenson, Redden)
Sidey, Robinson, Beams, Franklin, Dangerfield, Martin, Treloar (Adams, Zorko)
I have 11 trades and 374,000 in the bank

my plans were to consolidate my team asap
so i was thinking what would be best
I could do straight swaps of Shiel and Smith for Ablett and Zaharakis. i know they aren't fully fat cows yet
or i could trade adams to chappy this week and then trade Jmac and shiel/smith for a rookie and ablett
which option do you think is best Chappy or zaha??
chappy uses an extra trade but is in great form

[HappyDEZ]

Tuff one. As you point out, Chappy is preferable one would think. I would wait & get Chappy if you think he will ave. 5 or so more than Zaha from here on in.

[chaosAD]

Great team mate, chappy is just hitting form and looking the goods but that's a great double trade this week GAJ and Zaha, not sure I could wait for Chappy, just get Zaha he's going super as well

[disco1992]

I can see chappy either killing it or having a rest!!! but i feel zaha should ave 95-100 for the rest of the season! do you guys think taylor adams and Jmac will be reliable over the bye rounds to play???

Great team mate, chappy is just hitting form and looking the goods but that's a great double trade this week GAJ and Zaha, not sure I could wait for Chappy, just get Zaha he's going super as well

cheers chaos i burnt many a trade trying to get a decent team and got lucky with maric over Hmac

[The_Captain]

Chappy yeoww!

[Chopps]

you must be ranked well, top team, sorry cant help heaps as i am considering the chapman trade also

[disco1992]

you must be ranked well, top team, sorry cant help heaps as i am considering the chapman trade also

Cheers I'm ranked around 2k I have made some shockers of rookie decisions which have held me back alot!! But I was like 20000th after 4 rounds

Chappy or zaha what do I do it's the hardest decision so far!!! I'm thinking zaha now

[Fenno]

Save the trades. You only have 11 left and still have to get through the byes. Yea you will gain ranks in the short term but good luck finishing top 10,000 by the end of the year with the amount of trades you will have left after the byes.

[Alka]

Consider that Chappy could be rested later too. Zaha is much less likely to be.

[disco1992]

Save the trades. You only have 11 left and still have to get through the byes. Yea you will gain ranks in the short term but good luck finishing top 10,000 by the end of the year with the amount of trades you will have left after the byes.

the trades actually help my byes believe it or not and it would leave me with 7 trades after round 13 which hopefully should be enough to cover injuries

[disco1992]

Consider that Chappy could be rested later too. Zaha is much less likely to be.

Yer thats what i was thinking chappy may average 3-5 more for the rest of the season IMO but zaha is likely to play every game!!
im just pissed that zaha got a repremand at tribunal today so his record isnt good anymore!!

[Colliwobblers]

do the double and i would strongly consider ROK.

Last 5 = 98 - 105 - 78 - 116 -109.

only downside he has two tough games during league finals if you care.

Ablett and Zaka or Rok this round is a big boost but Chappy after sidebottom and Beams has to be the best fwd option overall, then stevie J at his best can outscore the lot of them....

tough choice good luck :)

[Fenno]

Save the trades. You only have 11 left and still have to get through the byes. Yea you will gain ranks in the short term but good luck finishing top 10,000 by the end of the year with the amount of trades you will have left after the byes.

the trades actually help my byes believe it or not and it would leave me with 7 trades after round 13 which hopefully should be enough to cover injuries

So your telling us you are only planning on making 2 trades over the bye rounds?

[Colliwobblers]

Save the trades. You only have 11 left and still have to get through the byes. Yea you will gain ranks in the short term but good luck finishing top 10,000 by the end of the year with the amount of trades you will have left after the byes.

the trades actually help my byes believe it or not and it would leave me with 7 trades after round 13 which hopefully should be enough to cover injuries

So your telling us you are only planning on making 2 trades over the bye rounds?

hmmm anyone who only trades twice over the byes is going to eat a lot of donuts, but they won't be alone there...

[disco1992]

do the double and i would strongly consider ROK.

Last 5 = 98 - 105 - 78 - 116 -109.

only downside he has two tough games during league finals if you care.

Ablett and Zaka or Rok this round is a big boost but Chappy after sidebottom and Beams has to be the best fwd option overall, then stevie J at his best can outscore the lot of them....

tough choice good luck :)

Yer i was thinking 2 trades would be good for 2 upgrades leaving me with only horse and giles on the field!!

but damn colli you made the choice harder adding the inform ROK aswell however do you think zaha should be on the up in an improving team???
cheers