Culling J-Mac? (WILL CHEER FOR HELP)

Started by Adamant, May 25, 2012, 08:19:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Am I stupid for trading J-Mac > Zorko?

Yes, dont do it!
15 (60%)
No, best option you've got.
7 (28%)
No Idea
3 (12%)

Total Members Voted: 1

auscoyote

Quote from: Colliwobblers on May 25, 2012, 08:23:02 PM
i would not do that, zorko isnt a must, the sydney boy (mitchell) is tearing it up scored 41 possessions in 70 minutes of football in the twos last week scored 171 SC points.

he will be in soon wait and fatten your rooks fully, trades cant be wasted on half fattened rooks at this stage of the season i reckon, AND if you can downgrade during the byes it will help with donuts, hopefuly mitchell debuts next round....

Magner can go any time he is fattened. magner to zorko this round.

again dont trade the other gws rooks not fattened and hall is a waste of a trade for next to no cash gain.
+1

I'd sit tight and keep milking the cows. I wouldn't trade old mac just to get zorko in. Magner is ready to be culled but the rest have money to be made. Couch also has to get a game soon with a ddp link.

Lions01

Quote from: Adamant on May 25, 2012, 08:28:47 PM
BTW Team is:

DEF: Goddard â€" Deledio â€" Birchall â€" Waters â€" Hargrave â€" Clarke â€" Bugg
(Spurr â€" Morris)

MID: Ablett â€" Boyd â€" Pendlebury â€" Jelwood â€" Rockliff â€" Horsely
(Magner â€" McDonald)

RUC: H-Mac â€" Giles
(Stephenson â€" Redden)

FWD: Franklin â€" Sidebottom â€" Beams â€" Robinson â€" Martin â€" Zaharakis - D.Smith
(Treloar â€" Hall)

What did you end up deciding on???
Nice side too mate, must be going alright overall

Adamant

Quote from: Lions01 on May 25, 2012, 08:48:44 PM
Quote from: Adamant on May 25, 2012, 08:28:47 PM
BTW Team is:

DEF: Goddard â€" Deledio â€" Birchall â€" Waters â€" Hargrave â€" Clarke â€" Bugg
(Spurr â€" Morris)

MID: Ablett â€" Boyd â€" Pendlebury â€" Jelwood â€" Rockliff â€" Horsely
(Magner â€" McDonald)

RUC: H-Mac â€" Giles
(Stephenson â€" Redden)

FWD: Franklin â€" Sidebottom â€" Beams â€" Robinson â€" Martin â€" Zaharakis - D.Smith
(Treloar â€" Hall)

What did you end up deciding on???
Nice side too mate, must be going alright overall
Cheers Lions,
I am ranked 1,590th overall after being 147th three weeks ago....having Rockliff captain for back-to-back 73's really hurt me  :(
I ended up sticking to my guns and went McDonald > Zorks, kinda regretting it already...

The_Captain

mcdonald will make you way more cash than trealor. I hope you kept him..

Chelskiman

Quote from: noto07 on May 26, 2012, 02:30:06 PM
mcdonald will make you way more cash than trealor. I hope you kept him..

He didn't.  Check one post above yours.  He's regretting it already.

Nails

How does it help your bye structure so much?

Rd 11 Bye > Rd 11 Bye player...

Not really much of a bye helper...

Adamant

Quote from: Nails on May 26, 2012, 07:22:38 PM
How does it help your bye structure so much?

Rd 11 Bye > Rd 11 Bye player...

Not really much of a bye helper...
Because Zorko is MID/FWD meaning I can sub Robinson/Martin(rd 13 BYE) into the MIDS and Zork up FWD...

Lions01

Not looking like a bad mover after all, Treloar killing it and Smith going ok.