ask the Coaches Round 9

[TheHanger]

Who to start out of Treloar, D Smith, T Adams

[Mr.Craig]

Who to start out of Treloar, D Smith, T Adams

Treloar and Smith.

[Holz]

Who to start out of Treloar, D Smith, T Adams

Treloar and Smith.

yes probably the easiest who to play question. keep adams on the bench.

[dreamkiller]

should i trade luke parker? b/e of 83 playing stkilda at etihad.

wanting to go him to ablett, but ablett's price might drop

waiting a week could save me some cash. thoughts?

[Spite]

should i trade luke parker? b/e of 83 playing stkilda at etihad.

wanting to go him to ablett, but ablett's price might drop

waiting a week could save me some cash. thoughts?

Abletts price will drop but parkers might. Plus you will lose points and miss out on gary's potentially big score. If you have got the cash, do it now and enjoy having GaJ (stick the big C on him too!)

[dreamkiller]

or should i hold, wait a week then go shiel to ablett and keep parker for few more rounds?

[Spite]

or should i hold, wait a week then go shiel to ablett and keep parker for few more rounds?

What is your midfield like? Will parker be your M6?

[dreamkiller]

by the end of yr probably not

pendles,boyd,selwood,parker,horsley,mcdonald (shiel,zorko)

420300k 15 trades?

[Spite]

by the end of yr probably not

pendles,boyd,selwood,parker,horsley,mcdonald (shiel,zorko)

420300k 15 trades?

In which case, I would suggest parker to mitchell while he has bottomed out and then do shiel to ablett next week. Leaves you with a very solid midfield line :)

[Tinka13]

who should be on the field for me this week and y?

Zorko - playing north melbourne, good form
treloar - essendon, average form
adams - essendon, average form
dickson - geelong tonight, good form


This will be crucial for me to get the win.

Opinions please pick 1 player!

[LaHug]

Swan to Stanton and play one of Horse and JMac
OR
Don't trade and play both Horse and JMac?

[Chopps]

should i trade luke parker? b/e of 83 playing stkilda at etihad.

wanting to go him to ablett, but ablett's price might drop

waiting a week could save me some cash. thoughts?

Abletts price will drop but parkers might. Plus you will lose points and miss out on gary's potentially big score. If you have got the cash, do it now and enjoy having GaJ (stick the big C on him too!)

abletts be is 135 price drop is going to be minimal if at all

[Holz]

who should be on the field for me this week and y?

Zorko - playing north melbourne, good form
treloar - essendon, average form
adams - essendon, average form
dickson - geelong tonight, good form


This will be crucial for me to get the win.

Opinions please pick 1 player!

dickson no, playing gellong i dont like that. adams no dont thnk he is that good. So its Zorko v Trealor close contest but i would go trealor.

[Holz]

Swan to Stanton and play one of Horse and JMac
OR
Don't trade and play both Horse and JMac?

If there was any question i wish i could answer corectly it would be this one, im asking myself the exact same thing. I originally made this move but after watch dt talk i reversed the trade, the big thing is if swan plays round 11 than it will be a bad trade if you do it.

Its also probably my anti eseenson nature kicking in but 615k for stants seems risky for me despite his form, i can just picture the padlock on him after the game and a 70 score. but playing gws and melbourne he could equally as likely knock up 2 150+ scores. Unforuntunately i cant help much but at this stage i have swan but who knows i might have Stanton as captain in 30 minutes

[henry]

Who should I start out of Morris and Darley? Morris is a 0% chance for the bench barring injury and darley is only a small chance I think. Morris averages 55, darley has 64 from his 1 game. Cheers.