Boyd or Thompson

[its me lads]

Want to bring in one of these guns. boyd is cheaper (by 1k) scotty t is more unique 26% own boyd a touch over 10% have thommo. both guns.

[tbagrocks]

love Thommo absolute gun, better player but....  Boydy would probably score higher ... just! and only just!

[Colliwobblers]

You can't go wrong, I went Boyd in DT and Thompson in SC.

Both scoring well, both going up in the next two or three weeks in value.

Boyd has a history of ending up very close to the highest average in DT for the season.

Thomo's draw just gets easier after the byes they could win most games with thier magoo's side.

[its me lads]

dont forget to vote in the poll, good points.

[Lions01]

Can't go wrong either way really, but as Colli said Boyd has made a habit of being at the top at the end of the year so I'd go with him

[Smeghead]

Yeah, win win choice here mate. I'd side with Boyd if I had to choose, but hey, I have both so I dont care  :P

Love a win win! :)

[powersuperkents]

I'd go Thompson, I want to try to get him into my team as well just a DT legend this season. Boyd's not unique enough and if you have tow of these three: Ablett, Swan or Stanton you don't really need another consistent scorer. Thompson is consistent this year he's more consistent then Boyd but when I had him last year he'd get either a 110 or a 130-160. I reacon go Thompson also because of the Crow current form

[Zombie2.5]

This is one of those ones that can surely go your way, whatever your decision. Good situation to be in!

But i'd have to say Boyd, every time i don't get him, i ALWAYS regret it!! He just guns it week in, week out whether his team wins or gets demolished. Even if he gets one or two sub-par games, he ALWAYS bounces back, normally with a massive score. I can expect a 110-120 score from boyd, plus the occasional 150+!!!

Thommo is a gun in the awesome crows ;) team right now and won't stop, won't let you down!
My favourite fact is, in every game the crows have won, he's scored 109+ and his lowest(59) was in the crow's only loss against Hawks!! Plus the easy draw can only help, not that it matters much actually, with 128, 138 and 121 against Syd, Cats and Blues!! His scores read: 135, 109, 59, 109, 138, 128, 138, 121!!!

A win-win either way, i reckon Boyd just and i only included more info on Scotty T cos i love him + crows!!
Scotty T is my picture too ;)

[its me lads]

yeah, the decision might come down to who i like more... which will be thommo cos im a crows man. :)

[its me lads]

i am torn

[Jukes]

I've had both all season as supporting figures for Stants, GAJ and Swanny but I reckon Thommo purely on recent form, from his last 4 his lowest score has been 121.

[its me lads]

still dont know what to do :o

[Chelskiman]

I love Thommo, but I love Boyd slightly more.  Both are guns though.  Honestly, flip a coin.  You can't go wrong either way here.

[mt_williams22]

An add-on to this thread....

I have both players and can not decide who to captain this week out of the two!

Any suggestions?

[its me lads]

as calvin said on dt talk live boyd has got 2 hundreds out of his last 15 against geelong so you would have to go thommo, that is another reason why i wont to pick thommo. but boydy did have a bad record against crows and he got 120 odd this year. food for thought..