Rate my defenders!

Started by verda32, February 08, 2010, 04:27:06 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

verda32

This is my current backline what do u rate it out of ten and why? C.Newman, C.Enright, L.Hodge, T.Kennelly, L.Henderson, R,Schoenmakers, M.Maguire EMG: P.Davis and J.Trengrove

Bs Flyers

I'd go an 8.5 (5 starters the same as my team ;D), depending on what happens at the Lions having Maguire as a starter could be very risky.  I've got him in my plans but as a backup not as a starter.  But NAB could show it to be a good choice and if he gets game time his value is sure to increase. 

haren-

i would rate it a 4.
you have 3 very average players starting in henderson, shoenmakers and maguire

Scratchy

Yeah thanks Haren for rating his backline based on what they did last year.

Obviously Schoenmakers set to get more games and TOG this year. Henderson 3rd season and a number 8 draft pick going to be a major focal point of a midfield with Judd Murphy and Gibbs has plenty of upside.
Maguire I had originally on the bench but then got too tight on funds and dropped him for Trengove but I think he's got more upside (used to average in the 60s, 70s for SC) and as good a chance if not better to play games than JT from Port.
Newman Enright and Hodge are all good picks, personally I'm a bit hesitant on Kennelly with his injury history and returning to AFL from Gaelic footy.

verda32

yeah good point, but kennelly was a great sc player averaging always above 80