Feedback greatly appreciated

[Bs Flyers]

Okay here it goes a mostly settled team now

Backs
Newman
Enright
Hodge
C Cornes
Kennelly
Rance
Sheppard

Maguire
Davis

Mids
Ablett
Pendlebury
Vince
Kerr
Trengrove
Martin

Morabito
Bastinac

Ruck
Clark
Kreuzer

Lobbe
Trengrove

Forwards
Pavlich
Franklin
Gray
Rioli
Buchanan
Dangerfield
Ziebell

Dennis-Lane
Gumbleton / Tapscott

Any feedback would be great and ratings to, thanks for your time.

[tphall]

Backs look solid, although keep an eye on Rance. Yes, he was meant to do 'big things' the last few seasons, but that don't mean he will do them now. I have Sheppard as one of my rookies, but going by the Eagles intra-club match he didn't do well, and pulled up proppy. One of watch also. Maguire should make a bit of cash for you.

Kerr in midfield may not be a good idea. Yes he is cheap, yes he has skills, but we all remember him from the days of the awesome Eagles midfield. He seems to be struggling for game fitness at the moment, and even if he is fit, I doubt he will be 100% by start of season. Maybe pick him up a few weeks into the season? 4 rookies in the middle is worrysome also.

Rucks look OK. Why not get Warnock? He is as cheap as those 2 rookies, but will definately be getting games. Good cash cow on the bench, aswell as backup on the field.

Robbie Gray is a unique choice, I hope it works out for you (I havent heard anything on him). Buchanan .... no.

[toodledock]

-solid backs similar to mine, do you have inside word about Cornes? As he could barely get over 70 last year and is now 31
-good mids, kerr is worth the gamble I reckon too WCE will be alot better this year
-2nd year rule on Clarke... he will prolly drop value unless of course he is a freak. Im on Kruez too, although if I keep hearing this stuff about him in thwe FWD line I might drop him, no cheap posi's in the fwds.
-risky forward line

[lozza63]

BS
Don't mind your squad at all
Backs - query re: Chad?

Mids quite strong heard that Kerr had an encouraging intra- club game, but he remains a query for us in the eastern states at least rest of the mids nice.

Rucks: not sure i subscribe to the 2nd year rule with Mitch he has been there since 2007 or so keep him if u like him, should be solid enough still!

The forwards are quite well spread all should get significant game time and the combination makes for a different flavour - the hope is that two of the picks 5-7 could make a break through to 80 odd pts per game - now your laughing.

Nice enough team no really glaring concerns.

[Bs Flyers]

Thanks a lot for that guys.

Hadn't heard that about Sheppard better watch out for that and I have my reservations about Rance as well - was thinking of changing to Hunt / Greenwood or Hunt / Schoenmakers instead of Rance / Sheppard depending on NAB.  Warnock still in my sights in and out of my team.

No inside word on Cornes had him last year and thought he should improve but would Gilbee or Carrazzo be better options?  Worried about Clark when there is actually a second ruck in the team maybe Jolly instead? toodledock could you expand on risky forward line.  Thanks again.

PS Sorry to not have commented on your teams but everyione had already brought up any issues I had.

[Bs Flyers]

Okey Dokey made some changes,

Backs
Newman
Enright
Hodge
Gilbee
Kennelly
Henderson
Schoenmakers

Maguire
Trengrove

Mids
Ablett
Pendlebury
Vince
Carrazzo
Trengrove
Martin

Morabito
Bastinac

Ruck
Tippett
Kreuzer

Warnock
Lobbe

Forwards
Pavlich
Franklin
Gray
Rioli
Dangerfield
Ziebell
Polkinghorne

Davis / Gumbleton
Dennis-Lane / Tapscott

and a whole $100 left over  ;D
Feedback has been great and more would be appreciated, also would anyone be able to give a mark out of 10? Thanks again.

[ando_10]

backs:really good plenty of depth 9/10

mids:7/10 carazzo intersting and the two rookies starting

rucks: 9/10 tippet and kruzeur good combo

Forwards:Even spread forward 7.5/10 hopefully ya can cover franklin for round 1 and i wouldnt take ziebell

[Bs Flyers]

Thanks ando, think Ziebell will have some second year blues?  Think there could be a better option than Carazzo?