Who would your top 6 MID's be?

Started by madskill55, May 22, 2012, 06:39:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ShaynoB

Surely Ablett, Swan, Pendles and Boyd r locks for being in everyones top 6 then u could throw a blanket over Thompson, Stanton, Watson and Jelwood.

I think Thompson and Jelwood personally

disco1992

I've had a change of heart and am struggling to see why i dont rate thompson!!! who would you guys choose 3 out of ablett, swan, pendles, thompson. I think they are all in the top 6 mids but i have mitchell as one of mine so which 3 would you choose

Zombie2.5

Quote from: disco1992 on May 23, 2012, 01:10:46 AM
I've had a change of heart and am struggling to see why i dont rate thompson!!! who would you guys choose 3 out of ablett, swan, pendles, thompson. I think they are all in the top 6 mids but i have mitchell as one of mine so which 3 would you choose
Easily Ablett, Swan and Pendles. Thommo is a gun but you can't quite rate him over these guys, who are plain and simple just guns. Not yet, anyways ;) I think Thommo has a lot more lower scores than these Super-mega-proven-premos. Pendles is still a little bit under the class of Swan and Ablett, but he's close and Thommo is lurking. If Thommo is great value(cheaper) when you do plan on doing the trade though, he's surely worth a look instead of Pendles. But imo, pendles will still average higher, but with the crows dominating and their easy draw, you can't go wrong with this machine.

crabapples

Gaj
Pendles
Swan
Jelwood
Deledio (not that id put him in my mid)
Stanton

disco1992

Quote from: Zombie2.5 on May 23, 2012, 01:26:46 AM
Quote from: disco1992 on May 23, 2012, 01:10:46 AM
I've had a change of heart and am struggling to see why i dont rate thompson!!! who would you guys choose 3 out of ablett, swan, pendles, thompson. I think they are all in the top 6 mids but i have mitchell as one of mine so which 3 would you choose
Easily Ablett, Swan and Pendles. Thommo is a gun but you can't quite rate him over these guys, who are plain and simple just guns. Not yet, anyways ;) I think Thommo has a lot more lower scores than these Super-mega-proven-premos. Pendles is still a little bit under the class of Swan and Ablett, but he's close and Thommo is lurking. If Thommo is great value(cheaper) when you do plan on doing the trade though, he's surely worth a look instead of Pendles. But imo, pendles will still average higher, but with the crows dominating and their easy draw, you can't go wrong with this machine.
i know and with swans hamstring and garys groin im leaning his way but i can't not put swan pendles and ablett in my team i need a LTI to sort it out!!! haha

Andrew

Every post contained "Pendles" or "Pendlebury." Maybe I should go Swan -> Pendlebury this week... Stanton just looks like a stand out, but $70k saved choosing Pendlebury instead.

If I could lock-in a top 6 to have come round 14 (after the byes and Swan injury), it'd be:

Swan, Ablett, Stanton, Pendlebury, Boyd, Thompson

But unfortunately I've got Joel Selwood who barley makes it into the top 10 most desirable :(

yorgis

already have gazza, swan, pendles, boyd, thommo and i can't decide who out of stants and watson [who is about $100K

cheaper]

Mr.Craig

Quote from: yorgis on May 23, 2012, 02:18:20 PM
already have gazza, swan, pendles, boyd, thommo and i can't decide who out of stants and watson [who is about $100K

cheaper]

I'm giving Jobe a go (in part because I'm 6k short of Stants.). It will be a bit of a novelty for me because I've never picked an Essendon mid before.

Chelskiman

Quote from: Mr.Craig on May 23, 2012, 03:41:43 PM
Quote from: yorgis on May 23, 2012, 02:18:20 PM
already have gazza, swan, pendles, boyd, thommo and i can't decide who out of stants and watson [who is about $100K

cheaper]

I'm giving Jobe a go (in part because I'm 6k short of Stants.). It will be a bit of a novelty for me because I've never picked an Essendon mid before.

Up until this year neither had I.  Watson has been immense for me all year.  I hope you don't jinx him. :P

Capper

Quote from: tbagrocks on May 22, 2012, 06:50:53 PM
Quote from: tabs on May 22, 2012, 06:48:10 PM
GAJ
Boyd
Swan
Pendles
Thompson
Stanton

Thompson has the best draw and must be up there

I was hoping a Freo mid would step up with their nice draw but none have stepped up yet
its not the draw that has Thommo on fire its the man himself!

just played Sydney, Geelong & Carlton, and he took them all to the cleaners
yeh true, but i meant his draw after the bye