Scott D. Thompson and Hanley

[powersuperkents]

They seem like inconsistent players that have the 50/50 chance of racking up a 80-100 or a 40-70 score. Is it worth bringing either in or should I downgrade a rookie like Paine for another rookie like Spurr. Is Bugg going to make anymore $ because his breakeven is high and I think now is the time to sell. I could do a direct trade Bugg to NathanThompson or Pearce Hanley or I'm thinking or downgrading Paine to Spurr in the backs and upgrading Bugg to Lake.

This is my team, please tell me what you think.

B: Godard, Broughton, Waters, Houli, Hargrave, Malceski, Bugg Bench: Paine, Redpath
C: Ablett, S Selwood, Ebert, Hayes, Rockliff, Horsley Bench: McDonald, Newell
R: McIntosh, Giles Bench: Redden, Stephenson
F: Sidebottom, Franklin, Dangerfield, Hawkins, Boomer Harvey, Waite, Dev Smith Bench: Treloar, Tay Adams

If I make a direct trade

B: Godard, Broughton, Waters, Houli, Hargrave, Malceski, Thompson/Hanley Bench: Paine, Redpath
C: Ablett, S Selwood, Ebert, Hayes, Rockliff, Horsley Bench: McDonald, Newell
R: McIntosh, Giles Bench: Redden, Stephenson
F: Sidebottom, Franklin, Dangerfield, Hawkins, Boomer Harvey, Waite, Dev Smith Bench: Treloar, Tay Adams

If I downgrade and upgrade win/win scenario unless Bugg makes 100

B: Godard, Broughton, Waters, Houli, Hargrave, Malceski, Lake Bench: Spurr, Redpath
C: Ablett, S Selwood, Ebert, Hayes, Rockliff, Horsley Bench: McDonald, Newell
R: McIntosh, Giles Bench: Redden, Stephenson
F: Sidebottom, Franklin, Dangerfield, Hawkins, Boomer Harvey, Waite, Dev Smith Bench: Treloar, Tay Adams

[The_Captain]

Well hanley did a hammy... so no on him. And thompsons best scores are over. But will still average above 100imo..

[powersuperkents]

shower soz i meant nathan thompson

[The_Captain]

who is nathan thompson lol?

[Mr.Craig]

I've got Hanley in my team. Would you like to take him off my hands? ;D

I think noto07 is a bit conservative with Thomo's average. I think it will be more like 110, making him worthy of serious consideration.

[powersuperkents]

I've got Hanley in my team. Would you like to take him off my hands? ;D

I think noto07 is a bit conservative with Thomo's average. I think it will be more like 110, making him worthy of serious consideration.

Its nathan not scott thompson he averages 80 he's from north melbourne no one has considered the second and probably better idea over whether I should downgrade Paine for Spurr and upgrade Bugg for Lake

[Mr.Craig]

LOL, well I still think you should get Scott. ;)

[The_Captain]

Probz not then. Not really a kepper imo. Go a better option. But yeh hanley is injured hey.

[powersuperkents]

Yeah I want him to but I'm waiting til Jmac makes enough. Scott Thompson always drops in price after mid season but still maintains his average

[Mr.Craig]

Yeah do the Paine>Spurr Bugg>Lake trade I guess.

[The_Captain]

yeh just get him after round 11 then !

[oldshepp]

Nathan Thompson now getting a kick for Kyneton in the Bendigo League.  Can't see him returning to AFL action any time soon !

[powersuperkents]

K sorry everyone I searched and It is actually Scott Thompson but Scott D. Thompson here is the link to his fanfooty page

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/players/profile.php?firstname=Scott%20D.&surname=Thompson

[Justin Bieber]

Scott Thompson scored well cause he was on that spud Gia haha

[powersuperkents]

Scott Thompson scored well cause he was on that spud Gia haha

Is he pretty much going to repeat his last few years and just be real inconsistent or will he maintain average?