Which upgrade option (Playing for league)

[Affliction]

Hi Guys

Below is my team:

D: Deledio, Goddard, Broughton, Shaw, Lake, Hargrave, Bugg
(Morris, Ellis)

M: Pendlebury, Boyd, Ablett, Greene, Coniglio, Horsley
(C.Smith, Shiel)

R: Cox, McIntosh
(Giles, Redden)

Sidebottom, Franklin, Martin, Dangerfield, D,Smith, Adams, Treloar
(Goodes, Hall)

$394,300 cash 18 trades left

Looking at 2 trades this week.

Ellis --> Spurr = new cash balance $498,400

Two options for my 2nd Trade (Can't decide which path)

Option 1

Shiel --> Beams

Option 2

Shiel --> Stanton


Next upgrade in the next couple weeks will be D.Smith --> Murphy if I go with option 1 or Coniglio --> Murphy if i go with option 2

Any suggestions to which is the better option.

Notes

1. Could of gone swan instead of stanton but will need murphy to drop to around $460-$465k in the next few weeks.

2. Will not be trading out Goodes, saving a trade instead (playing for league finals not rankings) or c.smith & hall rookie sideway trades are a waste of a trade IMO will trade out later in the year if they increase in value.

3. Option 1 will leave me me roughly $80k after i bring in murphy to use on next upgrade.

4. Not concerned about the byes - playing in 2 cash leagues & my trading to so far has given me all league wins so far and it allows me to lose all league matches during the bye rounds & still be up there.

[Affliction]

The poll is even.

Will also downgrade to Zorko next week.

Any suggestions? Do I go the midfielder or mid/fwd for better team structure & cash leftover