Which Back (Poll)

Started by Windigo, May 15, 2012, 05:21:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which Is Best? Take Byes Into Consideration AS Well!

Lake
1 (3.7%)
Waters
5 (18.5%)
Birchall
8 (29.6%)
Suckling
5 (18.5%)
Shaw
8 (29.6%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Windigo

Getting Lake or Waters is the best for byes. Also Shaw.

Means possible trade

Round 11

Hargrave
Bugg
Waters/Lake

Round 12:

Broughton
Heppell
Smedts
Shaw


Round 13:


Goddard
Deledio
Morris
Birchall/Suckling




Justin Bieber

I'm not so Shaw  ???

Nah I would get Waters over Lake.

Shaw is gem now.

Birchall will be more consistant than Suckling.

Chopps

i'd say shaw but 4 out in rd 12 doesnt look good

nathan11

Quote from: Chopps on May 15, 2012, 08:35:21 PM
i'd say shaw but 4 out in rd 12 doesnt look good
I'd pick shaw as well and either trade out smedts or move him forward

Colliwobblers

Who are you trading out? then I can answer :)

T Dog

#5
On a tangent here Windigo but Lake, Shaw and Suckling may just bust out 120+ on any given week and offset a spud zero in a bye round :o. Only of interest if you are going overall not the league of course  8)

Windigo

Quote from: T Dog on May 15, 2012, 09:33:27 PM
On a tangent here Windigo but Lake, Shaw and Suckling may just bust out 120+ on any given week and offset a spud zero in a bye round :o. Only of interest if you are going overall not the league of course  8)

..Can I say both.  :P

Quote from: Colliwobblers on May 15, 2012, 08:57:57 PM
Who are you trading out? then I can answer :)

Golby...

Quote from: nathan11 on May 15, 2012, 08:40:43 PM
Quote from: Chopps on May 15, 2012, 08:35:21 PM
i'd say shaw but 4 out in rd 12 doesnt look good
I'd pick shaw as well and either trade out smedts or move him forward

I've traded Ellis>Zorko via the Smedts DPP. As I don't trust L.Spurr.

Seriously, what is wrong with Lake? I've decided that I'll have to go with either Brian or Beau. And currently, Lake is looking the goods. Playing well and is playing GC this week?  ???

Please note that instead of Saad it's Zorko & Smedts is in the back line for Ellis.   ;)



Bones Bombers

Lake/Waters makes your byes worse IMO. You would have to trade Bugg to avoid a donut rd11 and then have to trade the player you bought in rd12/13. Unless of course you are wanting to get rid of Bugg soon.
I would leave Bugg and Hargrave as your 2 rd11 players and get Shaw, Birchall or Suckling. You will have to trade rookies in rd12 and 13 to avoid more than one donut anyway. Everyone will have 3 premos from one of the rounds and have to take 1 donut.
Best to look at your league opponents(if you care about league) and see which one is weakest, rd12 or 13 and take your donut there.

Dutchie64

I'd be inclined to get either Birchall or Suckling as it doesn't mess with your bye structure too much....

The_Captain

SUCKLING!!!!!! then birch..