FFS GIBBS

[essendon2]

He's sitting in M6 - at 450k, I can trade him to Horsley who's 300k+ cheaper and will probably only score 20 less.

then upgrade Kennedy --> Beams which will gain me a potential of 80!

Im definitely leaning towards it, but what do you guys think?

[shezz150]

go for it i guess. his break even is 115 so gib will go down again probz.

[essendon2]

why the flower are people voting yes?

[Justin Bieber]

How many of these Gibbs threads do you make?

[chaosAD]

Keep mate, i was in the same boat with Zeibell and im keeping, hell come good

[essendon2]

how do i get Horsley then??

and if I keep Gibbs, I have to play Milera and Treloar

[Zombie2.5]

Trade. The Horse will probably average the same as Gibbsy anyway and you make tons of money, getting beams in the process. Beams is a gun and it's really Gibbs, Kennedy and 2 trades v Beams and Horse. I'd easily take Beams and Horse plus you're cashing in a rook in Milera to a gun, so really you're getting an extra premo.

why the flower are people voting yes?

Well it is a poll.... could go either way.
Maybe they are mixing up trade gibbs(yes) and Keep gibbs(no).

[essendon2]

Trade. The Horse will probably average the same as Gibbsy anyway and you make tons of money, getting beams in the process. Beams is a gun and it's really Gibbs, Kennedy and 2 trades v Beams and Horse. I'd easily take Beams and Horse plus you're cashing in a rook in Milera to a gun, so really you're getting an extra premo.

why the flower are people voting yes?

Well it is a poll.... could go either way.
Maybe they are mixing up trade gibbs(yes) and Keep gibbs(no).

thanks mate, I am definitely agreeing with you.
Horsley is 300k cheaper but will only score 20 less.
Beams will deffs beat Kennedy by 60+

[Zombie2.5]

Trade. The Horse will probably average the same as Gibbsy anyway and you make tons of money, getting beams in the process. Beams is a gun and it's really Gibbs, Kennedy and 2 trades v Beams and Horse. I'd easily take Beams and Horse plus you're cashing in a rook in Milera to a gun, so really you're getting an extra premo.

why the flower are people voting yes?
[/quote
Well it is a poll.... could go either way.
Maybe they are mixing up trade gibbs(yes) and Keep gibbs(no).

thanks mate, I am definitely agreeing with you.
Horsley is 300k cheaper but will only score 20 less.
Beams will deffs beat Kennedy by 60+

:) 8)

;)

[Windigo]

You obviously haven't heard of Beau Muston.

[Spite]

Gibbs is coring badly because he is playing carrazzo's role. When carrots comes back expect him to average atleast 105 per game. The only problem is that you are doing well so you need to get the best players on the park. How many trades left? Is there another way you can get in horsely this week and upgrade somewhere else (back or forwards probably) because surely that will give you more points.

[essendon2]

Gibbs is coring badly because he is playing carrazzo's role. When carrots comes back expect him to average atleast 105 per game. The only problem is that you are doing well so you need to get the best players on the park. How many trades left? Is there another way you can get in horsely this week and upgrade somewhere else (back or forwards probably) because surely that will give you more points.

i've got 17 trades left.
I can go Shiel/JMac -- > Horsley
but then miss out on Ellis --> ROK by $800  :'(

381k to spend on whoever if I get rid of Ellis.
350k if i get rid of Kennedy

(without getting rid of Gibbs)

You obviously haven't heard of Beau Muston.

I have haha  :o

[CrowsFan]

You obviously haven't heard of Beau Muston.

Very valid point

[Spite]

mmm keep shiel and jmac for now... thats a hard one...

go gibbs to horse and kennedy to beams, hope it pays off!!! :O

[Plastic Boy]

Do not trade Gibbs, he is not injured and your trades are far too valuable to be getting rid of him.

He's a gun but is playing in defense a but rather then midfield, but this week against the saints at Etihad, it has 100+ written all over it