Having trouble deciding still

[the raven]

Still really having trouble deciding on a fwd premium. One will have to come in for kennedy in the fwd line. Only problem is I am not really sold on any of these. Mostly looking for a consistent player who will avg 90-95 at seasons end. Hard to split this group up.

If i get rid of magner this week (which i dont really want to) I could bring in beams with ease instead. But is beams really likely to be a 100-110 avg player with ball out?

[thanme]

If I had to pick from those 4, I'd go Zaharakis.

[jabroni]

pav because fyfes out

[picker_man]

id go pav two solid ton's and hardly saw him

[Mr.Craig]

Mostly looking for a consistent player who will avg 90-95 at seasons end.

Jordan Lewis. Ave - 90

Scores so far - 89, 86, 86, 101, 91, 90.

5 scores over 120 last season, due to go big soon.

[BGK]

If I had to pick from those 4, I'd go Zaharakis.

I agree. I like Zaha as an option. But I prefer other round 12 bye players, Beams, Sidebottom, Chapman etc. but if they are all you can afford I'd go Zaharakis.

[the raven]

Lewis would mean 4 rd 13 premiums in fwd line so dont really want that. Only way I can get players like chapman and beams is if i trade magner which i dont really want coz ive got useless smith in mids.

[essendon2]

Beams ???

Stevie J

[Colliwobblers]

BEAMS ! is he really a ....... he is ELITE !

just in case you want a little proof...

2011:

Description    Date    Opponent         K    HB    D    M    G    B    T    HO    GA    GC    I50    FF    FA    DT    SC
Round 24    2nd Sep    Geelong        14    15    29    7    1    0    7    0    1    2    2    2    0    129    114
Round 23    26th Aug    Fremantle       16    15    31    7    2    0    5    0    0    2    6    0    1    128    121
Round 22    20th Aug    Brisbane       19    11    30    3    1    1    3    0    0    1    6    3    1    107    117
Round 21    12th Aug    St Kilda        14    11    25    8    2    0    4    0    1    3    4    0    1    113    108
Round 20    6th Aug    Port Adelaide    15    17    32    9    3    1    4    0    2    5    9    1    0    142    179
Round 19    31st Jul    Essendon       15    10    25    2    2    1    3    0    1    3    2    2    0    98    76
Round 11    4th Jun    St Kilda            11    11    22    1    0    1    4    0    2    2    2    0    0    75    107
Round 10    29th May    West Coast     10    16    26    5    0    1    4    0    0    0    1    0    1    91    89
Round 9    22nd May    Adelaide        13    8    21    3    1    1    4    0    1    2    7    1    0    88    99
Round 5    25th Apr    Essendon       8    4    12    5    2    0    0    0    1    3    3    0    0    59    59
Round 4    15th Apr    Richmond        11    12    23    8    2    0    2    0    0    2    4    1    0    102    96
Round 3    8th Apr    Carlton             8    13    21    7    0    1    1    0    1    1    4    1    1    74    65
Round 2    2nd Apr    North             12    14    26    10    3    1    3    0    3    6    5    0    3    116    102
Round 1    26th Mar    Port Adelaide    12    7    19    5    2    0    6    0    0    2    4    0    0    101    79

Past Dream Team Average Scores
   
Year    Games    Average
2009    16    75.9
2010    21    87.0
2011    14    101.6
2012    5    102.0

[tbagrocks]

I did myseelf a favor and left Adams & traded Milera to Beams, must have imo

[upthemaidens]

rok value

[Zombie2.5]

I'd say Pav, just over ROK.
Pav is a proven gun, durable and well, he's a gun.
ROK gets injured, he's consistent but he doesn't get many high scores.

ROK for consistentency and proven. Pav for proven gun, capable of big scores if he kicks a few goals.
Cloke isn't exactly in great form and Zaha is a decent option while he's cheap but his breakout was last year, generally breakout players slow down a bit the next year.

[the raven]

Only way to get beams is if i trade magner and keep clay smith. are the points worth the lack of depth on the bench?

[upthemaidens]

I'd say Pav, just over ROK.
Pav is a proven gun, durable and well, he's a gun.
ROK gets injured, he's consistent but he doesn't get many high scores.

ROK for consistentency and proven. Pav for proven gun, capable of big scores if he kicks a few goals.
Cloke isn't exactly in great form and Zaha is a decent option while he's cheap but his breakout was last year, generally breakout players slow down a bit the next year.

rok has barely missed a game in the last 5 years, pav misses alot more.   

[Zombie2.5]

I'd say Pav, just over ROK.
Pav is a proven gun, durable and well, he's a gun.
ROK gets injured, he's consistent but he doesn't get many high scores.

ROK for consistentency and proven. Pav for proven gun, capable of big scores if he kicks a few goals.
Cloke isn't exactly in great form and Zaha is a decent option while he's cheap but his breakout was last year, generally breakout players slow down a bit the next year.

rok has barely missed a game in the last 5 years, pav misses alot more.

Yeah....... must be mixing him up with somebody else...

But i'd still pick Pav over Rok, Just!

Pav's more gun 8)