Horsely, Adams or neither?

Started by Goolahbah, May 09, 2012, 08:17:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which option?

McEvoy -> Cox, Magner-> Horsely
McEvoy -> Cox, Magner-> Adams
McEvoy -> Cox, Goodes-> Beams/Robinson
Other

Goolahbah

Initially traed in Horsely but then realise I dont have DPP in my midfield so it might come in handy with adams

Backs
Goddard birchall broughtom dempsey Scotland Ellis bugg (morris darley)

Mids
Pendlebury, Murphy, Hayes, Ablett, Magner, shiel (Greene coniglio)

Rucks
Mcevoy giles (redden Stephenson)

Fwds
Martin, n riewoldt, Franklin, Sidebottom, Goodes, christenson, hall (Kennedy, hampton)

Ps got only $1,400 left with 20 trades and im only really focusing on league

Thunderstruck

#1
I would do Mcevoy to Maric and sheil to horsley and hold goodes for a week.

However if you really want to move Goodes on them him Beams 8)

betch ya

both - could trade shiel for adams, switch goodes inti mid with adams in fwd, then downgrade goodes 4 horsley. doesnt leave u with a dpp but not the be all and end all in my opinion. u do get both good rooks in and a possible double upgrade next week. mite b another dpp 2 come through soon?

betch ya

just seen ya had mcevoy in ruck, probs just bring in horsley i
reckon.

Zombie2.5

Option 1....
You definitely would want Horsley and seeing as you have cover.... in you forwards you can give your bench the goodes.
You can do McEvoy to Maric/H-mac/Sandi/Cox and get horsley for magner.

And i just realised, these are gonna be my trades too ;)
I'm doing McEvoy > Maric and Magner > Horsley

Alka

Quote from: Zombie2.5 on May 09, 2012, 10:29:27 PM
Option 1....
You definitely would want Horsley and seeing as you have cover.... in you forwards you can give your bench the goodes.
You can do McEvoy to Maric/H-mac/Sandi/Cox and get horsley for magner.

And i just realised, these are gonna be my trades too ;)
I'm doing McEvoy > Maric and Magner > Horsley

+1. Jacobs is also a viable option for rucks, I'm surprised no one is mentioning him. At a good price, able to score big.

Jukes

You could do a lot better then Cox tbh

mad dawg

Maric is pretty risky, I wouldnt pick him

elephants

I'd get both and Maric as the ruck.

Thunderstruck

Quote from: Alka on May 09, 2012, 11:05:45 PM
Quote from: Zombie2.5 on May 09, 2012, 10:29:27 PM
Option 1....
You definitely would want Horsley and seeing as you have cover.... in you forwards you can give your bench the goodes.
You can do McEvoy to Maric/H-mac/Sandi/Cox and get horsley for magner.

And i just realised, these are gonna be my trades too ;)
I'm doing McEvoy > Maric and Magner > Horsley

+1. Jacobs is also a viable option for rucks, I'm surprised no one is mentioning him. At a good price, able to score big.

Agree Jacobs is an option however if he is playing Giles as well then that is 2 rd 11 byes so double donut...Safer option and who is scoring 80+ is Maric and suits the bye structure...

Zombie2.5

Quote from: Thunderstruck on May 10, 2012, 06:26:25 PM
Quote from: Alka on May 09, 2012, 11:05:45 PM
Quote from: Zombie2.5 on May 09, 2012, 10:29:27 PM
Option 1....
You definitely would want Horsley and seeing as you have cover.... in you forwards you can give your bench the goodes.
You can do McEvoy to Maric/H-mac/Sandi/Cox and get horsley for magner.

And i just realised, these are gonna be my trades too ;)
I'm doing McEvoy > Maric and Magner > Horsley

+1. Jacobs is also a viable option for rucks, I'm surprised no one is mentioning him. At a good price, able to score big.

Agree Jacobs is an option however if he is playing Giles as well then that is 2 rd 11 byes so double donut...Safer option and who is scoring 80+ is Maric and suits the bye structure...

Yeah, Jacobs and Maric are scoring similar but with Maric in better form.
Not sure who's cheaper, but Maric with the Rd 13 bye is extremely useful.

Torpedo10

You don't need DPP, Horsley Is worth more than a DPP link.  :o