What does everyone think about these 2 trades?

[Judd Magic]

Hi guys,

First time poster, long time lerker.  ;D

I was wondering if I could get some advice on a couple of trades I am thinking of doing this week.

I have a few senarios -

a) Kennedy > Adams

b) Dempsey Waters/Heppell

c) Porplyzia > Dangerfield


Which 2 do you think would most benefit my team?

I have $481,500 in the kitty.  :D

Who is the better pick out of Waters and Heppell and why? Both averaging 94 at the moment and hard to split.  ???

I want to upgrade Magner to Dal Santo next week and get Ablett back in a week after he comes back.

Here is what my team looks like -


B- Goddard, Deledio, Broughton, Malceski, Hargrave, Dempsey, Bugg (Ellis, Morris)

C- Pendlebury, J.Selwood, Barlow, McDonald, Horsley, Shiel (Magner, C.Smith)

R - MacIntosh, Giles (Redden, Stephenson)

F - Franklin, Goodes, Chapman, Martin, Sidebottom, Zaharakis, Porplyzia (Kennedy, hall)


All opinions welcome.

Cheers guys.  8)

[HappyDEZ]

Obviously the Goodes injury will change things for you but I like the look of your team esp. with 481K in the kitty. I like Heppells reliability (injury/tribunal) over his short career compared to waters so i would go Heppell if you went a trade in your backs. Maybe keep Porps for a bit & go Goodes to Cloke, Pav, Clancy or Danger & Kennedy to Adams. Good Luck

[coolfugitiv0]

You've got some cash to work with. Good.
This week, Goodes --> Danger, Kennedy --> Adams.


What about Lake as a defender? He's showing some very decent form right now.

But next week, your #1 priority should be strengthening that midfield!
You're looking at Ablett, which is good, but definitely get M.Murphy in there as well.

[Judd Magic]

Thanks for the feedback guys.


Yeah the Goodes injury has thrown a spanner in the works now for sure.

I just came up with this plan before. Let me know what you think?


Goodes > Dangerfield

Porplyzia > Adams

Brings bank balance up to $728,000.   :)


Next week -


Magner > Ablett

Shiel > Murphy

Sound like a plan?  ;D

[coolfugitiv0]

Do Kennedy --> Adams instead of Porps --> Adams

Porps BE is 34  and is averaging 76 over the last 3 rounds, compared to Kennedy who's BE is 56 and is averaging 51.3 over the last 3 rounds.

Wait a couple weeks on Porps, he still has cash to make, though he'd make a serviceable F7/8 imo.

[Judd Magic]

Do Kennedy --> Adams instead of Porps --> Adams

Porps BE is 34  and is averaging 76 over the last 3 rounds, compared to Kennedy who's BE is 56 and is averaging 51.3 over the last 3 rounds.

Wait a couple weeks on Porps, he still has cash to make, though he'd make a serviceable F7/8 imo.

If I do that though then I wont have enough money to brign in both Ablett and Murphy next week.

I know what you mean though mate.....

[Colliwobblers]

DO THAT and can you afford to bring in Ablett and Dal Santo ?