Ask Q (4/5/12)

[Master Q]

Like always, ask me a question, and I'll give you my honest opinion. Please do not answer any questions for me, if you want to start a discussion, start a thread!   ;)

If you'd like to thank me, don't be afraid to give me a cheer   ;)

Thread closes at 6:20 PM EST, I also have a team  ;) 

Thanks
-Q! 

---

And a bit of advertising  :P

If you haven't voted yet, please vote for me in Personality of the Year Competition 

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,45929.0.html

[Chopps]

Q, beams/chappy & goodes which one and why?

[essendon2]

DEF is God, Lids, Harg, Clarke, Bugg, Ellis, Morris (Smedts, Darley)
MID is Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Pendles, Rockliff, Gibbs (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC is Sandi, Giles (Redden, Orren)

should I go...

Sandilands > Maric & then Devon Smith > Broughton

OR

Ablett > Horsley & then Redden > Maric + 290k

OR

Sandilands > Maric & then Morris > Duffield

and why?
cheers Q

[nickstiges]

Mr Q, Fyfe out for which forward under 430k and why?

[Nails]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,57801.0.html

Please Q? :)

I'll cheer you after I brb :)

[PowerBug]

And a bit of advertising  :P

If you haven't voted yet, please vote for me in Personality of the Year Competition 

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,45929.0.html

haha, not sure which way to take this comment. ;) I'll keep you in mind Q, got a couple of questions for you first:


James Magner, Dylan Shiel, Stephen Coniglio, my 5th-7th midfielders. Which ones stay, in which order do they go?? Is it worth trading to a Jesse Stringer, Darren Pfeiffer or Crisp this week.

I have Tomlinson in my backline, he has played a couple of games, but has been dropped this week. His price is only ~180k, is there anyone i could go to?? Or should i wait for Lee Spurr (From my fave SANFL side) to play 2 more games??

[jamesalex]

Have 19 trades left.

Trade Redden to Longer to avoid a donut? Or trade Sandi to HMac? Or cop the donut against a good opponent in my league who has no donuts.

Thanks

[essendon2]

Have 19 trades left.

Trade Redden to Longer to avoid a donut? Or trade Sandi to HMac? Or cop the donut against a good opponent in my league who has no donuts.

Thanks

+1

[Lucastorm]

What are the chances Marty Clarke will be playing a tagging role tonight? If so, is it worth playing Morris or Ellis over Clarke?

Also, is D.Smith likely to play a full game, or be sub affected? If so, is it worthwhile upgrading him to Zaha, ROK, Pav or Clancee this week, or just wait another week?

Cheers

[Master Q]

Beams - Looking at his scoring, very overpriced atm.
Goodes - Average of 88 with 100 last round. 450k.
Chapman - BE of 81 and has scored well each round except against the Roos (58). Very good value at 430k.

So in order I'd go - Chappy, Goodes, Beams.

[Master Q]

DEF is God, Lids, Harg, Clarke, Bugg, Ellis, Morris (Smedts, Darley)
MID is Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Pendles, Rockliff, Gibbs (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC is Sandi, Giles (Redden, Orren)

should I go...

Sandilands > Maric & then Devon Smith > Broughton

OR

Ablett > Horsley & then Redden > Maric + 290k

OR

Sandilands > Maric & then Morris > Duffield

and why?
cheers Q

None. Trading Sandi and GAJ out is taking out big scores and replacing them with Midpricers/Maric.

Thought about Redden or Big O to Billy L?

Mr Q, Fyfe out for which forward under 430k and why?

Dustin Martin or Cloke? Only 2 that really are proven except Whitcross but I'm not sold on him.

[essendon2]

DEF is God, Lids, Harg, Clarke, Bugg, Ellis, Morris (Smedts, Darley)
MID is Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Pendles, Rockliff, Gibbs (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC is Sandi, Giles (Redden, Orren)

should I go...

Sandilands > Maric & then Devon Smith > Broughton

OR

Ablett > Horsley & then Redden > Maric + 290k

OR

Sandilands > Maric & then Morris > Duffield

and why?
cheers Q

no mate, not none..
I'm doing one of them - and the Redden > Billy L will gain me 50 points this week - so not worth it.

[Master Q]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,57801.0.html

Please Q? :)

I'll cheer you after I brb :)

Yeah. I'd go McCarthy --> to someone like Horsley and then Hall to Mitch Rob.

Seems like the only thing you can really do....

And a bit of advertising  :P

If you haven't voted yet, please vote for me in Personality of the Year Competition 

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,45929.0.html

haha, not sure which way to take this comment. ;) I'll keep you in mind Q, got a couple of questions for you first:


James Magner, Dylan Shiel, Stephen Coniglio, my 5th-7th midfielders. Which ones stay, in which order do they go?? Is it worth trading to a Jesse Stringer, Darren Pfeiffer or Crisp this week.

I have Tomlinson in my backline, he has played a couple of games, but has been dropped this week. His price is only ~180k, is there anyone i could go to?? Or should i wait for Lee Spurr (From my fave SANFL side) to play 2 more games??

Cogs then Shiel then Magner (Cogs to go first) unless of cash reasons. Don't need to downgrade.

And no, don't trade Tomlinson - assuming you don't have a donut.

[hugebbq]

22 trades left and 127k in da bank

fwds: Franklin, Robinson, Sidebottom, Goodes, Martin, Fyfe, D. Smith (Kennedy, Hall)

Need to replace Fyfe. Looking at ousting smith and Fyfe for 2 players to finish my forwards.

who to bring in as season keepers?

1. Cloke and Christensen
2. Pav and Zaha/Christensen
3. Dangermouse and Zaha/Christensen

[Master Q]

Have 19 trades left.

Trade Redden to Longer to avoid a donut? Or trade Sandi to HMac? Or cop the donut against a good opponent in my league who has no donuts.

Thanks

Wouldn't go Sandi to Hmac. Up to you if you want to trade to Longer or sit tight I guess.

What are the chances Marty Clarke will be playing a tagging role tonight? If so, is it worth playing Morris or Ellis over Clarke?

Also, is D.Smith likely to play a full game, or be sub affected? If so, is it worthwhile upgrading him to Zaha, ROK, Pav or Clancee this week, or just wait another week?

Cheers

Stick with Marty IMO.

Wait another.