Ask Q (4/5/12)

[Master Q]

DEF is God, Lids, Harg, Clarke, Bugg, Ellis, Morris (Smedts, Darley)
MID is Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Pendles, Rockliff, Gibbs (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC is Sandi, Giles (Redden, Orren)

should I go...

Sandilands > Maric & then Devon Smith > Broughton

OR

Ablett > Horsley & then Redden > Maric + 290k

OR

Sandilands > Maric & then Morris > Duffield

and why?
cheers Q

no mate, not none..
I'm doing one of them - and the Redden > Billy L will gain me 50 points this week - so not worth it.

Well that's just what I think  :P

[bombers1234]

Should I trade ablett out or hold him. If I hold him I still won't get any donuts and my next best captain choice after ablett is boyd.

Thanks

[Master Q]

22 trades left and 127k in da bank

fwds: Franklin, Robinson, Sidebottom, Goodes, Martin, Fyfe, D. Smith (Kennedy, Hall)

Need to replace Fyfe. Looking at ousting smith and Fyfe for 2 players to finish my forwards.

who to bring in as season keepers?

1. Cloke and Christensen
2. Pav and Zaha/Christensen
3. Dangermouse and Zaha/Christensen

Pav and Zaha  :-\

[Master Q]

Should I trade ablett out or hold him. If I hold him I still won't get any donuts and my next best captain choice after ablett is boyd.

Thanks

How many trades? What does your midfield look like?

[hugebbq]

Cheers,

Was heading that way

[essendon2]

DEF is God, Lids, Harg, Clarke, Bugg, Ellis, Morris (Smedts, Darley)
MID is Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Pendles, Rockliff, Gibbs (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC is Sandi, Giles (Redden, Orren)

should I go...

Sandilands > Maric & then Devon Smith > Broughton

OR

Ablett > Horsley & then Redden > Maric + 290k

OR

Sandilands > Maric & then Morris > Duffield

and why?
cheers Q

no mate, not none..
I'm doing one of them - and the Redden > Billy L will gain me 50 points this week - so not worth it.

Well that's just what I think  :P

what about, keep Sandi and go
Smith > Pfeiffer
&
Morris > Duffman

[bombers1234]

Should I trade ablett out or hold him. If I hold him I still won't get any donuts and my next best captain choice after ablett is boyd.

Thanks
How many trades? What does your midfield look like?

My midfield is boyd, thompson, hayes, ablett, magner and greene with shiel and d.smith on the bench and I've got 22 trades left.

[Master Q]

DEF is God, Lids, Harg, Clarke, Bugg, Ellis, Morris (Smedts, Darley)
MID is Swan, Boyd, Ablett, Pendles, Rockliff, Gibbs (McDonald, Shiel)
RUC is Sandi, Giles (Redden, Orren)

should I go...

Sandilands > Maric & then Devon Smith > Broughton

OR

Ablett > Horsley & then Redden > Maric + 290k

OR

Sandilands > Maric & then Morris > Duffield

and why?
cheers Q

no mate, not none..
I'm doing one of them - and the Redden > Billy L will gain me 50 points this week - so not worth it.

Well that's just what I think  :P

what about, keep Sandi and go
Smith > Pfeiffer
&
Morris > Duffman

Not a fan of Duffman.

Should I trade ablett out or hold him. If I hold him I still won't get any donuts and my next best captain choice after ablett is boyd.

Thanks
How many trades? What does your midfield look like?

My midfield is boyd, thompson, hayes, ablett, magner and greene with shiel and d.smith on the bench and I've got 22 trades left.

Why not bench GAJ?

[bombers1234]

Should I trade ablett out or hold him. If I hold him I still won't get any donuts and my next best captain choice after ablett is boyd.

Thanks
How many trades? What does your midfield look like?

My midfield is boyd, thompson, hayes, ablett, magner and greene with shiel and d.smith on the bench and I've got 22 trades left.
Why not bench GAJ?

I was thinking of benching him but I'm not sure if he's worth it sitting on the bench, especially when some say he could be out for up to another four weeks. Do you reckon I should just leave him on the bench (as I still won't get a donut) or just trade him?

[hugebbq]

22 trades left and 127k in da bank

fwds: Franklin, Robinson, Sidebottom, Goodes, Martin, Fyfe, D. Smith (Kennedy, Hall)

Need to replace Fyfe. Looking at ousting smith and Fyfe for 2 players to finish my forwards.

who to bring in as season keepers?

1. Cloke and Christensen
2. Pav and Zaha/Christensen
3. Dangermouse and Zaha/Christensen

Pav and Zaha  :-\

Or use 1 trade chappy in for fyfe and keep smith?

[footy4life]

Thoughts on

Mccarthy OUT --> Christensen IN

And then sub Smith into the midfield for Christensen.

This will allow me next week to go

Smith OUT --> Horsley IN

And then use the cash for another upgrade.

Cheers :)

[Master Q]

Should I trade ablett out or hold him. If I hold him I still won't get any donuts and my next best captain choice after ablett is boyd.

Thanks
How many trades? What does your midfield look like?

My midfield is boyd, thompson, hayes, ablett, magner and greene with shiel and d.smith on the bench and I've got 22 trades left.
Why not bench GAJ?

I was thinking of benching him but I'm not sure if he's worth it sitting on the bench, especially when some say he could be out for up to another four weeks. Do you reckon I should just leave him on the bench (as I still won't get a donut) or just trade him?

Everyone has the same problem... I'm benching because I have other problems but If you don't and have a hard game/push ranking then it's not such a bad move.

[Master Q]

22 trades left and 127k in da bank

fwds: Franklin, Robinson, Sidebottom, Goodes, Martin, Fyfe, D. Smith (Kennedy, Hall)

Need to replace Fyfe. Looking at ousting smith and Fyfe for 2 players to finish my forwards.

who to bring in as season keepers?

1. Cloke and Christensen
2. Pav and Zaha/Christensen
3. Dangermouse and Zaha/Christensen

Pav and Zaha  :-\

Or use 1 trade chappy in for fyfe and keep smith?

Well going in No.2 brings in a Premium in Pav and a almost premium in Zaha.

[Master Q]

Thoughts on

Mccarthy OUT --> Christensen IN

And then sub Smith into the midfield for Christensen.

This will allow me next week to go

Smith OUT --> Horsley IN

And then use the cash for another upgrade.

Cheers :)

Toughy  :-\ What are your thoughts in Christensen? TBH I'm not sold on him.

[Lucastorm]

Thanks Maester Q