Trading Thompson or Ablett to Joel Selwood?

Started by Jukes, May 03, 2012, 12:16:18 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to trade to Joel?

Scott Thompson
2 (9.1%)
Gary Ablett
2 (9.1%)
Don't trade him in.
18 (81.8%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Jukes

Really keen on Joel after his mammoth 178 last year against the Dees at Skilled, really want him in, only two mids I'd trade to him are Scotty Thompson and Gary Ablett (have some $$$ left so price is not an issue upgrading Thommo). Scotty has been quite poor but Ablett could be out for a few more. Who should I trade, if I do it?

And can anybody tell me how long GAJ is gonna be out for now?

Justin Bieber

I wouldn't get rid of Scotty T after his mammoth performance last week... Trading Ablett is pretty much one week late as there is still a chance he will play next week... Wait a couple weeks on Joely S, he will be a great bargain in weeks to come.

Praetorian

Yeah, I wouldn't be trading him in just because you reckon he'll go well this week! Both those trades seem unnecessary. You'll feel like a right pill if he doesn't carve up the Dees after all.

BarnDogg

Am I on drugs or did Scotty T get 138 last week?

Justin Bieber


BarnDogg

Quote from: whatlez on May 03, 2012, 12:36:29 PM
Drugs mate.

Thanks for letting me know, some more questions... What did he actually score? Did the Crows even beat Port? I was at the game, maybe I was cheering for the wrong team???????

Justin Bieber

Quote from: BarnDogg on May 03, 2012, 12:38:29 PM
Quote from: whatlez on May 03, 2012, 12:36:29 PM
Drugs mate.

Thanks for letting me know, some more questions... What did he actually score? Did the Crows even beat Port? I was at the game, maybe I was cheering for the wrong team???????

Hahaha

Hey Jukes are you thinking of trading Thommo cause they are versing Sydney?

danger


Either trade is foolish.

GAJ will be back with a vengeance sooner than you think.

Thommo hasn't quite killed it, but has been OK, can only get better from here. Don't forget the crow's draw..

Jelwood will get weeks / jail time for assaulting a tagger at some stage this year.. pencil it in.

crabapples

isn't jelwood still uncertain to even plan on the weekend?

Praetorian

Quote from: danger on May 03, 2012, 01:14:34 PM
Thommo hasn't quite killed it, but has been OK, can only get better from here. Don't forget the crow's draw..

Going to get harder before it gets easier.

Crows' next five:

Sydney @ SCG
Geelong @ AAMI
Carlton @ Etihad
Collingwood @ AAMI
Freo @ Paterson's

Then the bye!

Andrew

Quote from: crabapples on May 03, 2012, 01:17:50 PM
isn't jelwood still uncertain to even plan on the weekend?


Yes he is, we won't know if he's playing until Friday...


Quote from: Praetorian on May 03, 2012, 01:20:33 PM
Quote from: danger on May 03, 2012, 01:14:34 PM
Thommo hasn't quite killed it, but has been OK, can only get better from here. Don't forget the crow's draw..

Going to get harder before it gets easier.

Crows' next five:

Sydney @ SCG
Geelong @ AAMI
Carlton @ Etihad
Collingwood @ AAMI
Freo @ Paterson's

Then the bye!


Ouch... not looking good for Thompson owners (includes me). I knew he'd struggle coming up but no way you could trade him this week after a 138.

tbagrocks

thay might be facing the top 4, but it won't stop scotty's numbers!!!!!!!!!!

Jukes

So defs not Thommo (I didn't think I'd end up trading him anyway after last week, just he's the weakest link bar injury in my midfield premiums). Doubt GAJ then either. He'll be back probably next week.

Cheers for the help lads.

Doyle

Why would you trade out S. Thompson?? *Jackie Chan face*

Windigo

Quote from: Jukes on May 03, 2012, 01:40:38 PM
So defs not Thommo (I didn't think I'd end up trading him anyway after last week, just he's the weakest link bar injury in my midfield premiums). Doubt GAJ then either. He'll be back probably next week.

Cheers for the help lads.

Have you seen his scoring apart from the one off game?  ???