Replacement for fyfe

[JKraz]

Hey guys, with fyfe going down again I think it looks at too great of a risk going forward, especially with his large BE,

If he was to undergo surgery or miss more games, who is the best sideways trade to go to? I personally am tossing up between zaha and beams, but i put in all available options just for completeness.

[fertalong]

Do you have a mid dpp? I do, and im planning to trade Fyfe to Murphy this week if Murphy isn't rested.
Otherwise, I'm leaning towards beams for a fwd replacement since I already have Mitch Robbo. If you don't have Robbo, then get him as a priority.

[Justin Bieber]

Are you caring about byes?

It looks like chapman is at the best value and they are verging Melbourne. Hopefully he scores though so I an get him next week ;D

[Colliwobblers]

Beams for the best score, ROK or Zaka for the best value, chappy to have a bit each way :)

[JKraz]

not overly fussed about byes as I am ranked 10k and can potentially kiss overall goodbye.

Also need to consider if robo is playing this week against gws

[Zombie2.5]

Robbo!! Gun and playing GWS is a bonus. I don't think they'd rest him, mostly Judd, Murphy, Scotland, Simpson, Kreuzer, their stars and really 'must have' guys or the older guys.

[Windigo]

Big balls to keep him around.

But this clearly is the time to oust.  ;)

Robbo or Beams.

[Smileys Bruisres]

Hi all,

I also have Fyfe and am looking at trading him for R.Okeefe as his price has dropped and i think he turned the corner last week.

What is peoples thoughts on him?

[Windigo]

Hi all,

I also have Fyfe and am looking at trading him for R.Okeefe as his price has dropped and i think he turned the corner last week.

What is peoples thoughts on him?

I'm on him. Arguably the most consistent FWD last year, had a run of 84+ for like 12 games and only 3 games below 80.  8)

First few rounds were dog shower because he was coming back from injury. But looks the goods.

But he is still a risk...But just having ROK in your FWD line just makes it 'look' better.  :P

[Justin Bieber]

I'm waiting one more week on ROK or not getting him.

It's either him or Zaha and I like the look of Zaha.

[Windigo]

Just further incentive:

Adelaide: High=138 Low=48 Average=91.44

Last 3: 100, 130 & 91

Then the week after he plays Tigers...Near enough to 100 average on them.  8)

[Smileys Bruisres]

Cheers Windigo you have put my mind at rest the ROK is going in & he plays Melbourne in the 3rd week also big points should be had against them 2.

[4820]

Christensen must be worh consideration I would have thought ?

[Windigo]

Cheers Windigo you have put my mind at rest the ROK is going in & he plays Melbourne in the 3rd week also big points should be had against them 2.

Just warning you that most of my tips on trade in have all be duds..Jay Z last week for instance.  ::)

But ROK under priced for what he can deliver.  ;)

Christensen must be worh consideration I would have thought ?

There are so many other options in this price bracket. Hawkins, Zaha, Pearce, ROK, Christensen etc. Some will get it right, and others will get it wrong.  :P

[dillez]

my forward line is

franks, sidebum, fyfe , martin, porps, D smith, Hall

I can afford to go fyfe to any fwd I want or

fyfe - dangerfeild
porps - pavlich?


good idea?

with fyfe out pay should get more time in the mid.