AFL's most decorated

[Capper]

Bartel, Swan, Ablet, Goodes, Black, Judd and i cant believe i am going to say this but Fletcher

Fletcher
All Australian
2 Premierships
1 b&F
350+ games and still going

[elephants]

Bartel would have been the first person I'd have said too!!

[crabapples]

Bartel would have been the first person I'd have said too!!

thats pretty much all i wanted to hear out of this thread lol ;D


i think the brownlow/premiership + having hair, won it over judd for me... allthough judds all australian record is huge..

[BGK]

It will be interesting to see who you would choose between Bartel and Judd at the conclusion of thier careers. Judd's resume is pretty impressive and as much as it pains me to say it Judd and Carlton may have more accolades to come.
Chris Judd


West Coast premiership captain 2006
Brownlow Medal 2004, 2010
West Coast Club Champion Award 2004, 2006
All-Australian Team 2004, 2006, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011
Ross Glendinning Medal Rd 3 2005, Rd 20 2005, Rd 6 2006
Norm Smith Medal 2005
West Coast captain 2006â€"2007
Leigh Matthews Trophy 2006, 2011
Carlton captain 2008â€"pres
John Nicholls Medal 2008, 2009, 2010,
John Nicholls Medal (Runner Up) 2011

[BGK]

Jimmy Bartel

AFL premiership medallion (2007, 2009, 2011)
2-time NAB Cup premiership winner (2006, 2009)
Brownlow Medal (2007)
2-time All-Australian (2007, 2008)
AFL Rising Star Nomination (2002)
Norm Smith Medal (2011)

Apart from winning 3 premierships I think Judd beats him.

[CrowsFan]

Judd has the fourth highest number of brownlow votes of all time. At the end of this season he will easily be third (only needs 17 votes to be equal) and could possibly be second (needs 30 to be equal). By the time his career finishes he will have the most brownlow votes ever, plus will most likely win another 1 so will be equal in most brownlows won.

So looking at Judds credentials he has...

2 Brownlows
1 Norm Smith
1 Premiership (could be another one this year)
2 Leigh Matthews Trophies (MVP for the season)
6 time All Australian, once as captain, twice VC
5 time club B&F

Plus has a hot girlfriend ;)

I pick being Judd

[CrowsFan]

Ah BGK just beats me to saying Judd is better. But at least someone agrees :)

[BGK]

Ah BGK just beats me to saying Judd is better. But at least someone agrees :)

I hate Judd because he plays for Carlton but I can't question that he will be remembered as one if the greats to play the game. IMO out of all today's players he will be remembered as the greatest. Ablett would probably be a close second.

[bomberboy0618]

Bartel, Swan, Ablet, Goodes, Black, Judd and i cant believe i am going to say this but Fletcher

Fletcher
All Australian
2 Premierships
1 b&F
350+ games and still going

Id love to be Fletcher. He barely trains and everyone loves him.

[Cookie Monster]

Michael Hurley <3

[BGK]

Michael Hurley <3

He's far from a champion. He has potential but that's it at the moment.

[Master Q]

Judd has the fourth highest number of brownlow votes of all time. At the end of this season he will easily be third (only needs 17 votes to be equal) and could possibly be second (needs 30 to be equal). By the time his career finishes he will have the most brownlow votes ever, plus will most likely win another 1 so will be equal in most brownlows won.

So looking at Judds credentials he has...

2 Brownlows
1 Norm Smith
1 Premiership (could be another one this year)
2 Leigh Matthews Trophies (MVP for the season)
6 time All Australian, once as captain, twice VC
5 time club B&F

Plus has a hot girlfriend ;)

I pick being Judd

I'd be love to see that list  :) Link?

[Ziplock]

Geelong leading goalkicker 2006
Geelong premiership side 2007, 2009
Leigh Matthews Trophy 2007, 2008, 2009
AFLCA Champion Player of the Year 2007, 2008, 2009
All-Australian team 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011
Carji Greeves Medal 2007, 2009
Brownlow Medal 2009
Gold Coast captain 2011â€"
Gold Coast Club Champion 2011

Ablett.

[crabapples]

@master q

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/brownlow/totals0.html

[CrowsFan]

@master q

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/brownlow/totals0.html

Pretty handy site :)