FARK THIS (go to 4th page now)

[essendon2]

Current Rank: 115  8)

My team is as follows:

DEF: Goddard, Lids, Carrazzo, Hargrave, Clarke, Bugg, Ellis (Morris, Darley)
MID: Swan, Pendles, Ablett, Boyd, Gibbs, McDonald (Magner, Shiel)
RUC: Sandi, Giles (Redden, Orren)
FWD: Franklin, Sidebottom, Robbo, Martin, Danger, Devon, Milera (Kennedy, Smedts)

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i go
Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field McDonald as M5 and Magner as M6)
Bank = $105k

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?) (field McDonald as M6)
(Play with 21)
Bank = $31k-131k


KEEP IN MIND:
Option 1 will win by 50+ points this week, but Rockliff/Ward will continue to beat Magner by 50 each week whereas when Sandilands is back HMac will only be beating Giles by 5-10

[essendon2]

2-2-2

it's really helping me  :-\

[Master Q]

I said 2 and so did a few others...

You are not "panicking".

[Windigo]

A lot of people are in the same circumstances.

Is a trade really worth maybe 80 points from H-Mac....Of course he could go higher, but you cannot assume.

[its me lads]

i absolutely hate copping a doughie so i went for the 1st opt

[blah128]

I say option 1

Magner and Kennedy not quite done making money yet...Magner ready to go next week or week after
Option 2 is next best though...will be a beastly midfield when GAJ comes back

[Justin Bieber]

Yeah to keep your ranking you should avoid donuts. But what does that mean next week? You play Sandi/Hmac and Giles on bench?

[blah128]

It would be nice if Giles could play every game but he will need a rest eventually, even with Brogan helping him. By the end of the year most people will want 3 rucks scoring well to cover for "managing" the big men and injuries when trades are running out. HMAC could prove to be a great 2nd/3rd ruck now that he is playing better than Goldy

[essendon2]

Yeah to keep your ranking you should avoid donuts. But what does that mean next week? You play Sandi/Hmac and Giles on bench?

yeah that's correct.

the bottom line is: (may sound confusing)

Option 1: = HMac's Score (Sandi, HMac, Giles, Redden)
vs
Option 2: = Difference between Rockliff and Magner (6 guns when Ablett is back)

Option 1 will win by 50+ points this week, but Rockliff/Ward will continue to beat Magner by 50 each week whereas when Sandilands is back HMac will only be beating Giles by 5-10.

[dicey7]

how can you trade carazzo to treloar? carrazzo is in ur backs while treloar is Mid/Fwd? i dont see a Def/Mid in your mids?

[Windigo]

He has Smedts. It's what I done.  ;)

[essendon2]

He has Smedts. It's what I done.  ;)

+1

[essendon2]

Option 1 will win by 50+ points this week, but Rockliff/Ward will continue to beat Magner by 50 each week whereas when Sandilands is back HMac will only be beating Giles by 5-10.  ???

[Justin Bieber]

Answered your question sort of.

[essendon2]

well Ward or Rockliff????  :o