Ask the Coaches Round 5

[Holz]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

Getting Treloar looks like a good thing to do IMO. If you get a sneaky premium upgrade then why not.  8)

Magner still has money to make and i would hold him for another week to see how he goes this week, certainlty not a bad trade as getting in trealor is a greta move he is a gun and should average well for a rookie. I have gone kennedy to trealor however as i feel kennedy has less money to make this week and isnt playing so will go up less in value, that also sovles your forward issue for the week.

I to want a DPP mid by bye time but pfiefer looks the goods and i plan on getting him next week, zorko is another possibility, its a little risky relying on one of these 2 but pfiefer should play for a while and playing his second game next week should be on the bubble and play next week.

Magner to trealor not a bad move but I would go Kennedy to trealor than Magner to Pfiefer next week.

given me more to think about there holzman  and that actually seems like a good idea ;D totally forgot about zorko (as needs to rd11 bye player). Can do the magner to zorko in 3 weeks pocket an extra 60k from mags, save a trade this week and will still have mcdonald for cover if zorko doesnt play hmmm.... means i miss out on the treloar train (possibly the only person) and might get a donut this week if hall doesnt play :-\

I would still recomend getting in trealor i rate him above pfiefer and zorko.

[LF]

Just traded Couch--> Treloar

Question is do i start Smith or Treloar?

[picker_man]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

Getting Treloar looks like a good thing to do IMO. If you get a sneaky premium upgrade then why not.  8)

Magner still has money to make and i would hold him for another week to see how he goes this week, certainlty not a bad trade as getting in trealor is a greta move he is a gun and should average well for a rookie. I have gone kennedy to trealor however as i feel kennedy has less money to make this week and isnt playing so will go up less in value, that also sovles your forward issue for the week.

I to want a DPP mid by bye time but pfiefer looks the goods and i plan on getting him next week, zorko is another possibility, its a little risky relying on one of these 2 but pfiefer should play for a while and playing his second game next week should be on the bubble and play next week.

Magner to trealor not a bad move but I would go Kennedy to trealor than Magner to Pfiefer next week.

given me more to think about there holzman  and that actually seems like a good idea ;D totally forgot about zorko (as needs to rd11 bye player). Can do the magner to zorko in 3 weeks pocket an extra 60k from mags, save a trade this week and will still have mcdonald for cover if zorko doesnt play hmmm.... means i miss out on the treloar train (possibly the only person) and might get a donut this week if hall doesnt play :-\

I would still recomend getting in trealor i rate him above pfiefer and zorko.

so maybe kennedy to treloar this week covers possible fwd donut and use extra cash for scotland over birchall next week
and go mags to a rd 11 DPP later on

[Holz]

Just traded Couch--> Treloar

Question is do i start Smith or Treloar?

I started trealor but its really a coin toss they will both score 65-85 in my opinion.

[LF]

Just traded Couch--> Treloar

Question is do i start Smith or Treloar?

I started trealor but its really a coin toss they will both score 65-85 in my opinion.

thats what i thought as well Thanks Holz i think i`ll go with my gut on this one.

[Holz]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

Getting Treloar looks like a good thing to do IMO. If you get a sneaky premium upgrade then why not.  8)

Magner still has money to make and i would hold him for another week to see how he goes this week, certainlty not a bad trade as getting in trealor is a greta move he is a gun and should average well for a rookie. I have gone kennedy to trealor however as i feel kennedy has less money to make this week and isnt playing so will go up less in value, that also sovles your forward issue for the week.

I to want a DPP mid by bye time but pfiefer looks the goods and i plan on getting him next week, zorko is another possibility, its a little risky relying on one of these 2 but pfiefer should play for a while and playing his second game next week should be on the bubble and play next week.

Magner to trealor not a bad move but I would go Kennedy to trealor than Magner to Pfiefer next week.

given me more to think about there holzman  and that actually seems like a good idea ;D totally forgot about zorko (as needs to rd11 bye player). Can do the magner to zorko in 3 weeks pocket an extra 60k from mags, save a trade this week and will still have mcdonald for cover if zorko doesnt play hmmm.... means i miss out on the treloar train (possibly the only person) and might get a donut this week if hall doesnt play :-\

I would still recomend getting in trealor i rate him above pfiefer and zorko.

so maybe kennedy to treloar this week covers possible fwd donut and use extra cash for scotland over birchall next week
and go mags to a rd 11 DPP later on

not sure about the scotland v birchall trade would need to look over it for the week but yeah i would get in trealor. It doesnt have to be a round 11 fwd/mid you get because you could awalys get in pfiefer and than swtich him with trealor.

[nickstiges]

Which 3 to start out of these forward rookies:

D. Smith, Milera, Treloar and Pfeiffer.
Already have Kennedy on the pine.

Thanks in advance. :)

[Capper]

killing it Holz, keep it up!

[Holz]

Which 3 to start out of these forward rookies:

D. Smith, Milera, Treloar and Pfeiffer.
Already have Kennedy on the pine.

Thanks in advance. :)

as i said before the rookies could score anything and its minaly luck, would definately start trealor. Milera playing the demons is a little bit of a risk but he could pay off with a good score. I dont expect pfiefer to get the sub but as he is the last on the interchange list and has only played 1 game he is a much greater chance than smith to be sub. Pfiefer might be able to score 10-15 more but if he is sub you will be unhappy.

Leave out pfiefer in my opinion if smith and him play a full game smith might beat him anyway.

[picker_man]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

Getting Treloar looks like a good thing to do IMO. If you get a sneaky premium upgrade then why not.  8)

Magner still has money to make and i would hold him for another week to see how he goes this week, certainlty not a bad trade as getting in trealor is a greta move he is a gun and should average well for a rookie. I have gone kennedy to trealor however as i feel kennedy has less money to make this week and isnt playing so will go up less in value, that also sovles your forward issue for the week.

I to want a DPP mid by bye time but pfiefer looks the goods and i plan on getting him next week, zorko is another possibility, its a little risky relying on one of these 2 but pfiefer should play for a while and playing his second game next week should be on the bubble and play next week.

Magner to trealor not a bad move but I would go Kennedy to trealor than Magner to Pfiefer next week.

given me more to think about there holzman  and that actually seems like a good idea ;D totally forgot about zorko (as needs to rd11 bye player). Can do the magner to zorko in 3 weeks pocket an extra 60k from mags, save a trade this week and will still have mcdonald for cover if zorko doesnt play hmmm.... means i miss out on the treloar train (possibly the only person) and might get a donut this week if hall doesnt play :-\

I would still recomend getting in trealor i rate him above pfiefer and zorko.

so maybe kennedy to treloar this week covers possible fwd donut and use extra cash for scotland over birchall next week
and go mags to a rd 11 DPP later on

not sure about the scotland v birchall trade would need to look over it for the week but yeah i would get in trealor. It doesnt have to be a round 11 fwd/mid you get because you could awalys get in pfiefer and than swtich him with trealor.

Awesome advice Holz double cheer ;)  to hard to explain but your help gets me a double upgrade next week ;D ;D ;D

[picker_man]

is this thread ongoing through out the season??? if so should be stickied yeah

[LF]

is this thread ongoing through out the season??? if so should be stickied yeah

Yes it will be i`m sure that the mods will sticky it they did in the supe rcoach section :)

[Justin Bieber]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,57227.0.html

[Ziplock]

tag in ziplock for questions :P

[Holz]

is this thread ongoing through out the season??? if so should be stickied yeah

it will and i will open it up as soon as teams are out each round, so we can answer more questions. I will probably be on when the thread is opened and a few hours before lockout.