Ask the Coaches Round 5

[Holz]

Q does his regular thread of advice each week but he gets a little swamped so we have decided some of the coachs would join to answer questions in a thread, so post away if you want advice.

[LF]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,57151.0.html

Hey guys could you help give this guy a hand I'm picking kids up from school and can't get the players prices on the DT app because of partial lockout

[Master Q]

Any questions  :)

[essendon2]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field McDonald as M5 and Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?) + (McDonald as M6)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field McDonald as M5 and Magner as M6)

[picker_man]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

[Windigo]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

Getting Treloar looks like a good thing to do IMO. If you get a sneaky premium upgrade then why not.  8)

[TheHanger]

My current situation is that I have just burned my DPP link to get in Greene (after round 2)
Now I don't have any DPPs in my mids
Treloar provides that link but I don't have any ripe rookies in my mids
I can get Treloar in for Kennedy (who is the rookie who is set to earn the least amount of money after this round, in my team)
And wait for Magner/Shiel/Greene to ripen before trading them out for the likes of Zorko/Couch/Docherty
Will Magner/Shiel/Greene start to lose value before Zorko n Co. play, will this happen before the byes when the DPP links are crucial?

What should I do???

[Holz]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field McDonald as M5 and Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?) + (McDonald as M6)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field McDonald as M5 and Magner as M6)

Option 1 would depend on how high you are ranked and whether you go for overall, I know your up the top so the move should keep you up the top.  However if you do that trade you would probably have to keep your ruck divison Sandi, Hmac, Giles all year. So in round 11 assuming big O isnt playing you will be copping a donut. The risk your taking is Redden may be back next week and for the season and if you have Sandi, Giles, Redden you avoid a donut than.

So 1 trade to avoid a certain donut but create a possible donut in the future. The seoncd question is can Hmac keep up his scoring, i tihnk he will average about 80-85 onwards from here on, if you happy with that than pull the trade but Im in the same situation and i would rather bring in a fit Mummy or Cox who will average 95+. Im in the same sitatuion similar rank and im holding keeping the trade, would rather use it to avoid a donut in the bye and im thinking redden will be back so, my advice is hold redden.

Option 2: I love rocky is the cheapest he will be all season in my opinion and looks like averaging 115+ from here on, makes up for the loss of ablett I would do that trade in a heartbeat.

Option 3: but late on waters doesnt represent that good value and rocky will smash his scoring output. Rocky Massively underpriced waters slightly underpiced.

[pinochio]

ye prob going dickson > treloar, since dicko is no where near playing!!
as for my plan to get pendles with kennedy to treloar, getting pendles needs shiel/smith culled but they still have money to be made after next round imo....

am i right in the dicko to treloar trade and reasoning why im not going kennedy out??

[picker_man]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

Getting Treloar looks like a good thing to do IMO. If you get a sneaky premium upgrade then why not.  8)

Yep i think your right  cheers windy ;D

[Windigo]

ye prob going dickson > treloar, since dicko is no where near playing!!
as for my plan to get pendles with kennedy to treloar, getting pendles needs shiel/smith culled but they still have money to be made after next round imo....

am i right in the dicko to treloar trade and reasoning why im not going kennedy out??

Kennedy should be back next week making you cash. Treloar will make you cash this week, Dicko is making you nothing, just making you have a headache. Oust to Treloar seems logical mate.  ;)

[Chopps]

ye prob going dickson > treloar, since dicko is no where near playing!!
as for my plan to get pendles with kennedy to treloar, getting pendles needs shiel/smith culled but they still have money to be made after next round imo....

am i right in the dicko to treloar trade and reasoning why im not going kennedy out??

Kennedy should be back next week making you cash. Treloar will make you cash this week, Dicko is making you nothing, just making you have a headache. Oust to Treloar seems logical mate.  ;)

Windigo beat me to it, +1 move dickson to treloar

[Holz]

found it haha
ok i was looking at trading magner to treloar this week as i need a mpp in my mids for bye time to save me from another donut. I thought this would also save me a donut this week as i could move him into the fwds for kennedy as i didnt think my two bench guys were playing (hall&couch) now hall might be playing is it still worth it??
2 things to note
this will not cost me  trade in the long run as without the mpp in the mids i will have to trade during rd 12 to avoid a donut
plus without the cash extra cash i cant get scotland next week and would have to look at birchall/sucking etc

Getting Treloar looks like a good thing to do IMO. If you get a sneaky premium upgrade then why not.  8)

Magner still has money to make and i would hold him for another week to see how he goes this week, certainlty not a bad trade as getting in trealor is a greta move he is a gun and should average well for a rookie. I have gone kennedy to trealor however as i feel kennedy has less money to make this week and isnt playing so will go up less in value, that also sovles your forward issue for the week.

I to want a DPP mid by bye time but pfiefer looks the goods and i plan on getting him next week, zorko is another possibility, its a little risky relying on one of these 2 but pfiefer should play for a while and playing his second game next week should be on the bubble and play next week.

Magner to trealor not a bad move but I would go Kennedy to trealor than Magner to Pfiefer next week.

[pinochio]

thx fellas!

immensely helpful as always in reassuring me :D

[Master Q]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field McDonald as M5 and Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?) + (McDonald as M6)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field McDonald as M5 and Magner as M6)

Option 1 would depend on how high you are ranked and whether you go for overall, I know your up the top so the move should keep you up the top.  However if you do that trade you would probably have to keep your ruck divison Sandi, Hmac, Giles all year. So in round 11 assuming big O isnt playing you will be copping a donut. The risk your taking is Redden may be back next week and for the season and if you have Sandi, Giles, Redden you avoid a donut than.

So 1 trade to avoid a certain donut but create a possible donut in the future. The seoncd question is can Hmac keep up his scoring, i tihnk he will average about 80-85 onwards from here on, if you happy with that than pull the trade but Im in the same situation and i would rather bring in a fit Mummy or Cox who will average 95+. Im in the same sitatuion similar rank and im holding keeping the trade, would rather use it to avoid a donut in the bye and im thinking redden will be back so, my advice is hold redden.

Option 2: I love rocky is the cheapest he will be all season in my opinion and looks like averaging 115+ from here on, makes up for the loss of ablett I would do that trade in a heartbeat.

Option 3: but late on waters doesnt represent that good value and rocky will smash his scoring output. Rocky Massively underpriced waters slightly underpiced.

That's what I thought (and said) in my thread as well  :)