Ask Q: Ruined Round 5 (27/4/12)

[matt1985]

One more question for you sorry Q!

Devon Smith is named last on the bench. Probably doesn't mean anything, but do you think there is a chance he could be made sub?

I have Hampton sitting on the bench as EMG, should I play Hampton over Smith?

Means nothing...

Thanks mate, your a champ!

[Master Q]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

I can't hold him because I have no cover :(
Any good options?

I'm copping the donut - Unless Big O plays  :P

Like I said earlier I'm not completely sure but if you narrow it down to 2 I'll give you my opinion  :)

One more question for you sorry Q!

Devon Smith is named last on the bench. Probably doesn't mean anything, but do you think there is a chance he could be made sub?

I have Hampton sitting on the bench as EMG, should I play Hampton over Smith?

Means nothing...

Thanks mate, your a champ!

Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

[Justin Bieber]

So should I start Ellis or Morris?

Pick 2: Coniglio, Shiel or Magner

Will Aaron Hall play?

Take a donut in the rucks cause of Sandi?

[Master Q]

So should I start Ellis or Morris?

Pick 2: Coniglio, Shiel or Magner

Will Aaron Hall play?

Take a donut in the rucks cause of Sandi?

Ellis

Magner and Cogs

Not sure like I said earlier

I am. But that's because I don't want to upgrade...

[dreamkiller]

murphy or mitchell or rockliff or thompson?

[LaHug]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

I can't hold him because I have no cover :(
Any good options?

I'm copping the donut - Unless Big O plays  :P

Like I said earlier I'm not completely sure but if you narrow it down to 2 I'll give you my opinion  :)

McIntosh, Roughead, Maric, Kreuzer. That's my shortlist right now...
Leaning towards McIntosh or Maric for potential to price ratio.

[Stocutz]

Thoughts on this please, is it crazy. Coming 1228 overall. Going for cash league (half money for overall pts half for premier)
$97,300 20 trades

Backs:
Lids God Waters Hargraves Broughton Duffield Bugg        Clarke Ellis

Mids:
Gaz Boyd Watson Pendles Magner McDonald       Shiel Greene

Rucks:
Giles Kruezer     Stephenson Redden

Fwds:
Robinson Sidebottom Franklin Dangerfield Martin Smith Porps      Kennedy Hall

Kennedy to Trelor (will do anyway was going to be porps but as kennedy is out he goes)
Ablett to Barlow
When Ablett is back get him in for either magner shiel greene
Cash out porps if I need the cash. thoughts

[Justin Bieber]

Ellis as last on extended bench?

[Master Q]

murphy or mitchell or rockliff or thompson?

Murphy for me... Mitchell right behind him.

[Master Q]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

I can't hold him because I have no cover :(
Any good options?

I'm copping the donut - Unless Big O plays  :P

Like I said earlier I'm not completely sure but if you narrow it down to 2 I'll give you my opinion  :)

McIntosh, Roughead, Maric, Kreuzer. That's my shortlist right now...
Leaning towards McIntosh or Maric for potential to price ratio.

Haha they are all the options  :P Out of Hmac and Maric I'd go Hmac.

Thoughts on this please, is it crazy. Coming 1228 overall. Going for cash league (half money for overall pts half for premier)
$97,300 20 trades

Backs:
Lids God Waters Hargraves Broughton Duffield Bugg        Clarke Ellis

Mids:
Gaz Boyd Watson Pendles Magner McDonald       Shiel Greene

Rucks:
Giles Kruezer     Stephenson Redden

Fwds:
Robinson Sidebottom Franklin Dangerfield Martin Smith Porps      Kennedy Hall

Kennedy to Trelor (will do anyway was going to be porps but as kennedy is out he goes)
Ablett to Barlow
When Ablett is back get him in for either magner shiel greene
Cash out porps if I need the cash. thoughts

I'd go Kennedy to Tre but not GAJ to Barlow...

[Master Q]

Ellis as last on extended bench?

According to your thread he is named...

[Justin Bieber]

Ellis as last on extended bench?

According to your thread he is named...

Whoops. Last on the bench. Not the extended.

[Master Q]

And that's it for this week  :) What a busy night  :o

If you still have questions go here -

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,57157.0.html

I might do some work there  :)

Thanks and Good Luck  8)
-Q