Ask Q: Ruined Round 5 (27/4/12)

[Master Q]

Hey Q, thanks in advance for the help....

DO i go Nic Nat or Coz for Mummy..... both averaging the same, Cox is a proven premium but not getting the same game time in the ruck.... Nic Nat on the way up and 50k cheaper ! Any advice is much appreciated

Cox... Nic Nat is no where near as proven as Cox.

Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

[tigers123]

G'Day Q,

Advice on who to start in my forward line:

Kennedy or Treloar!

Cheers mate :)

[Master Q]

G'Day Q,

Advice on who to start in my forward line:

Kennedy or Treloar!

Cheers mate :)

Kennedy ain't playing  ;)

[essendon2]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field Magner)

Leaning towards 2. When you say 21 and field Magner do you mean Magner as M6?

Magner as M6 means that McDonald is at M5.
Option 2 means I play with 21 because of Sandi.. why are you leaning towards it? can i have an explanation please  ;D

Simply because Rocky is better than HMac and Waters IMO. Only thing is you'll have 21 this week but I'm not sure if it's worth forcing Hmac into your team...

I'm simply stuck, Hmac playing GC, Ziebell playing GC :\
Rockliff or Ward? ergh
Get Hmac to save a zero, but then have to field Magner?

[stevieg1980]

Hey Q, thanks in advance for the help....

DO i go Nic Nat or Cox for Mummy..... both averaging the same, Cox is a proven premium but not getting the same game time in the ruck.... Nic Nat on the way up and 50k cheaper ! Any advice is much appreciated

Cox... Nic Nat is no where near as proven as Cox.

Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

Thanks Q, ill lock in Cox which means that Nic Nat will probably score 200 . haha
Ledger out for Treloar is a no brainer isnt it......

[tigers123]

G'Day Q,

Advice on who to start in my forward line:

Kennedy or Treloar!

Cheers mate :)

Kennedy ain't playing  ;)

oh shower haha didn't even realise...

any idea who is in for risch? Hall?

If so treloar or hall?

[Master Q]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field Magner)

Leaning towards 2. When you say 21 and field Magner do you mean Magner as M6?

Magner as M6 means that McDonald is at M5.
Option 2 means I play with 21 because of Sandi.. why are you leaning towards it? can i have an explanation please  ;D

Simply because Rocky is better than HMac and Waters IMO. Only thing is you'll have 21 this week but I'm not sure if it's worth forcing Hmac into your team...

I'm simply stuck, Hmac playing GC, Ziebell playing GC :\
Rockliff or Ward? ergh
Get Hmac to save a zero, but then have to field Magner?

Rockliff.

Hey Q, thanks in advance for the help....

DO i go Nic Nat or Cox for Mummy..... both averaging the same, Cox is a proven premium but not getting the same game time in the ruck.... Nic Nat on the way up and 50k cheaper ! Any advice is much appreciated

Cox... Nic Nat is no where near as proven as Cox.

Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

Thanks Q, ill lock in Cox which means that Nic Nat will probably score 200 . haha
Ledger out for Treloar is a no brainer isnt it......

Yup.

[Zombie2.5]

Ok,

One of Morris/Smedts (Have Bugg & Ellis already on field)

Three of Magner/Greene/Coniglio/Shiel, leaning towards benching Greene.

Also i don't have any donuts and i have 21 trades, $9k cash
Should i do the Kennedy > Treloar?
I've always thought treloar was good, just didn't play first two games so i left him out of my team.
And who do you reckon will replace Rischitelli as he's pulling out? Aaron Hall?

P.S. Cheers! and Cheerio for you my good man :) 8)

[Master Q]

G'Day Q,

Advice on who to start in my forward line:

Kennedy or Treloar!

Cheers mate :)

Kennedy ain't playing  ;)

oh shower haha didn't even realise...

any idea who is in for risch? Hall?

If so treloar or hall?

Hall ain't playing.

http://www.afl.com.au/teams/tabid/16469/default.aspx

[matt1985]

One more question for you sorry Q!

Devon Smith is named last on the bench. Probably doesn't mean anything, but do you think there is a chance he could be made sub?

I have Hampton sitting on the bench as EMG, should I play Hampton over Smith?

[Master Q]

Ok,

One of Morris/Smedts (Have Bugg & Ellis already on field)

Three of Magner/Greene/Coniglio/Shiel, leaning towards benching Greene.

Also i don't have any donuts and i have 21 trades, $9k cash
Should i do the Kennedy > Treloar?
I've always thought treloar was good, just didn't play first two games so i left him out of my team.
And who do you reckon will replace Rischitelli as he's pulling out? Aaron Hall?

P.S. Cheers! and Cheerio for you my good man :) 8)

Morris I guess...

Earlier I think I said Magner, Greene, Cogs  :-\

Yeah I guess, the 100k is great  :)

Not to sure TBH  :-\

[Master Q]

G'Day Q,

Advice on who to start in my forward line:

Kennedy or Treloar!

Cheers mate :)

Kennedy ain't playing  ;)

oh shower haha didn't even realise...

any idea who is in for risch? Hall?

If so treloar or hall?

Hall ain't playing.

http://www.afl.com.au/teams/tabid/16469/default.aspx

O wait you means who will replace Risch  :P Not so sure TBH  :-\

[Master Q]

One more question for you sorry Q!

Devon Smith is named last on the bench. Probably doesn't mean anything, but do you think there is a chance he could be made sub?

I have Hampton sitting on the bench as EMG, should I play Hampton over Smith?

Means nothing...

[Master Q]

15 Minutes Left  :)

And a bit of advertising  :-X

If you haven't voted yet, please vote for me in Personality of the Year Competition  :)

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,45929.0.html

[LaHug]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

I can't hold him because I have no cover :(
Any good options?