Ask Q: Ruined Round 5 (27/4/12)

[essendon2]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field Magner)

[Master Q]

Quickie: who to start? Magner, Coniglio, JMac or Sheil. Need 3!

Magner, JMac and Cogs (Just).

Coniglio > Murphy,

or

Porplyzia > Robinson (or any other premo mid)

or

hold trades, rookies still have cashola to make, however kind of need to trade to ensure league win

Definitely Cogs to Murphy. Rookies will still make money  :P

[picker_man]

hey Q,

Kennedy to Treloar and pocket the 100k to allow me to get pendles/murphy next week with pfiffer..
OR
Cull Dickson for Treloar who dosent seem to play lol

dicko out is kinda sideways but then again he is just sitting there....theyll be other like zorko/neale etc to cut dicko....


which one kennedy or dickson for treloar...its doing me head in!!!


thx

I think you might have to go for Dicko to Tre. Good long term plan... But if you don't think you'll need heavy cover each round then Kennedy to Tre (What I'm probably going to do as I need it) is the way to go.

This question always gets me to think IMO. If you can't decide I'd probably go Dicko to Tre  :-\

PS: Don't be afraid to Cheer  ;)

Hey Q nothing to do with this round but interested on seeing how many trades you think i will need to have left from rd 13 onwards. If (all going to plan) my team will be  set with 22 premo's / 8 rookies and only need the trades for injuries/suspensions/players rested etc

Not so sure... I'd say 10... Rough guess.

i was thinking 7 thats close enough to 10 for me haha cheer 2 u

[Master Q]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

[Master Q]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field Magner)

Leaning towards 2. When you say 21 and field Magner do you mean Magner as M6?

[Master Q]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

Hmac looks like a decent option, might leave you in trouble for the bye round though, but with Goldy dropped and the Roos playing GC could have a another big game.

Holz, read the opening post please  :)

[Holz]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

Hmac looks like a decent option, might leave you in trouble for the bye round though, but with Goldy dropped and the Roos playing GC could have a another big game.

Holz, read the opening post please  :)

Sorry all, good the ask the coaches thread is failing, but great work as always.

[picker_man]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

Hmac looks like a decent option, might leave you in trouble for the bye round though, but with Goldy dropped and the Roos playing GC could have a another big game.

Holz, read the opening post please  :)

Sorry all, good the ask the coaches thread is failing, but great work as always.

where is the ask the coaches thread?? that could be the problem...

[Master Q]

is darren pfeiiffer playing

i traded him in for ablett monday and it wont let me reverse him and i heard he was out??

what do you think of my trading plan

this week

ablett to pfeiffer $550,000 in account

next week

clay smith to neale $600,000 in account
dickson to zaharakis $300,000 in account

week after

greene to boyd $100,000
magner to horsley 250,000 in account

week after

morris to goddard 0 in account

I think he's playing  :-\ I haven't seen any team updates though... Can't do reverse trades after Partial.

Zaha?  :-\

[strikes91]

is darren pfeiiffer playing

i traded him in for ablett monday and it wont let me reverse him and i heard he was out??

what do you think of my trading plan

this week

ablett to pfeiffer $550,000 in account

next week

clay smith to neale $600,000 in account
dickson to zaharakis $300,000 in account

week after

greene to boyd $100,000
magner to horsley 250,000 in account

week after

morris to goddard 0 in account

and then you never get ablett back...

[Master Q]

Have to trade out Mummy and only have $4400 in cash. Any advice on who to get?

Also have to go Mummy. Also want to downgrade  :-\

Atm I'm holding, If you are downgrading want to go to a Rookie you'll have to wait... Or take a huge risk on Cordy. If you want to downgrade to a Mid-Pricer, TBH, I don't know  :-[

Hmac looks like a decent option, might leave you in trouble for the bye round though, but with Goldy dropped and the Roos playing GC could have a another big game.

Holz, read the opening post please  :)

Sorry all, good the ask the coaches thread is failing, but great work as always.

where is the ask the coaches thread?? that could be the problem...

It is  ::)

[essendon2]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field Magner)

Leaning towards 2. When you say 21 and field Magner do you mean Magner as M6?

Magner as M6 means that McDonald is at M5.
Option 2 means I play with 21 because of Sandi.. why are you leaning towards it? can i have an explanation please  ;D

[Master Q]

is darren pfeiiffer playing

i traded him in for ablett monday and it wont let me reverse him and i heard he was out??

what do you think of my trading plan

this week

ablett to pfeiffer $550,000 in account

next week

clay smith to neale $600,000 in account
dickson to zaharakis $300,000 in account

week after

greene to boyd $100,000
magner to horsley 250,000 in account

week after

morris to goddard 0 in account

I think he's playing  :-\ I haven't seen any team updates though... Can't do reverse trades after Partial.

Zaha?  :-\

he is under 400k it is between him or pavlich

I'd say Pav but let's see how he goes tonight.

[stevieg1980]

Hey Q, thanks in advance for the help....

DO i go Nic Nat or Coz for Mummy..... both averaging the same, Cox is a proven premium but not getting the same game time in the ruck.... Nic Nat on the way up and 50k cheaper ! Any advice is much appreciated

[Master Q]

I have Sandi, and no bench cover
Also still have Carrots..

should i
go Carrazzo > Treloar
Redden > HMac (play with 22) (field Magner as M6)

Option 2:
Carrazzo > Treloar
Magner > Rockliff/Ward/Ziebell (which one?)
(Play with 21)

Option 3:
Carrazzo > Waters
Kennedy > Treloar
(Play with 21 & field Magner)

Leaning towards 2. When you say 21 and field Magner do you mean Magner as M6?

Magner as M6 means that McDonald is at M5.
Option 2 means I play with 21 because of Sandi.. why are you leaning towards it? can i have an explanation please  ;D

Simply because Rocky is better than HMac and Waters IMO. Only thing is you'll have 21 this week but I'm not sure if it's worth forcing Hmac into your team...