Advice Required Please!

[Mozza84]

Have Ablett and Sandilands....

Thinking Ablett to JMac.... then leaves me with $540,700 spare.

Then thinking Stephensen to HMac... leaving me with $292,900 in the bank and 20 trades.

Mids are then: Boyd, Mitchell, Selwood, Thompson, JMac, Magner (Shiel, Neale)

Rucks: are then: HMac, Giles (Sandilands, Redden)

Good? or Bad?

[Lucastorm]

Is it really worth trading GAJ out when you know he will return and smash it?

[Mozza84]

I have been tossing up all week on what to do... I want to keep Gaz, but then likely to cop a donut in the ruck..
Plus getting JMac will make me some $$$
Would envisage to get Gaz back when he returns, but a downgrade/upgrade..
Which would leave me with 18 trades... and I wouldn't expect to use any more until Bye rounds
Barring LTI's etc.

The only other option is to trade Sandilands.... but I just got him in last week for Mumford...

Thoughts?

[LF]

Looking at your mids trading Ablett out would be a mistake simply because you already have 4 other premo mids and you can afford to bench ablett

[LF]

How much cash do you currently have left?
Also what is your whole team?

[Lucastorm]

Same boat as you, traded him for HMac and hope I don't live to regret it down the track...

Pro's are that HMac should go alright this weekend, and I made some extra cash, which can be spent upgraded fwd's and mid's next week....

Injury plague hurts.

Also a thing to remember, it may not be as easy as thought to get GAJ back, and not having him when he is tearing shower up would be more of a disaster in the long-term.

[Mozza84]

Current team is:
Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Waters, Birchall, Bugg, Clarke, Ellis (Smedts, Darley)
Mids: Boyd, Mitchell, Selwood, Thompson, Magner, Shiel (Ablett, Neale)
Rucks: Sandilands, Giles (Redden, Stephensen)
Fwds: Franklin, Fyfe, Goodes, Martin, Porplyzia, D.Smith, Hall (A.Kennedy, J.Cameron)

Current Cash is $46,500

What can I do to avoid a donut in my rucks?

[crabapples]

the only solution i can see is to trade sandi..  :P..

[Holz]

Where are you ranked and are you going for overall or league, if league hold off. IM ranked just outside the top 500 and i go for overall and at this stage im coping the Sandi donut.

[Mozza84]

Ranked around 18 thousand....Just going for league win.

I copped 2 donuts (fyfe, birchall) last week and still managed to win all my league games.

So might just leave Sandi in, and cop the 1 donut this week.

Should I trade Neale to Treloar, then swap him with Kennedy, then trade Kennedy to JMac to make some coin?

[LF]

Yeah cop the Sandi donut
Trading Neale to Treloar would be a good move its going to make you money and give you an emergency for your mids

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

what about porplyzia -> treloar and if you REALLY want JMac trade out magnet.

KEEP ABLETT!!! you'll have an abundance of cash to spend next week on a premium in your forwards or backs. iunno too premature to trade anybody out of your side! I'd cop the donut!

[Mozza84]

Thinking of going Neale to JMac....... then starting Magner and JMac, with Shiel as Emergency

A.Kennedy / Cameron / Hall to Treloar?

[LF]

Yep definately start MacDonald and Magner
if you must have Treloar then trade Cameron-->Treloar