The Who To Start Thread

[elephants]

I am keen to start a weekly thead where everyone posts their starting of subs conundrums.

I won't be on fanfooty 24/7 (like whatlez) so when you post a question it'd be swell if you were also able to answer a few at the same time.

This would be helpful to everyone to gather together a few opinions.

Me first -

Ellis or Bugg or Morris

and

Shiel or McDonald or Coniglio

Okay Shoot!

Remember to answer a few before you ask ;)

Cheers.

[shezz150]

i hav the same 3 in back as u do. so im seeing Ellis with the bloody orange emrg dot so ive got bugg on field and morris as emg.

i cant speak for coniglio. im still waiting for shiel to pump out a ton or atleast something above bloody 80 so id go macca over him.

in my case i hav to choose between shiel, greene or magner as an emg. got gazza taking the other spot.

anyone know if magner is gonna be sticking with the tagging role that ruins his score?

[jabroni]

feel bugg and old mac are the safest

[elephants]

Couldn't be sure about Mangers role but I reckon Shiel is due for a good score :)

[Lucastorm]

Couldn't be sure about Mangers role but I reckon Shiel is due for a good score :)

Your feeling may make me field Oldmac --> Shiel .... can you handle it?!


In reply to the thread:

Bugg, Oldmac

[Adamant]

which 3 of: Shiel, Coniglio, J-Mac & Magner?

and

which 1 out of: Ellis, Morris & Bugg?

Cheers

[Adamant]

I am keen to start a weekly thead where everyone posts their starting of subs conundrums.

I won't be on fanfooty 24/7 (like whatlez) so when you post a question it'd be swell if you were also able to answer a few at the same time.

This would be helpful to everyone to gather together a few opinions.

Me first -

Ellis or Bugg or Morris

and

Shiel or McDonald or Coniglio

Okay Shoot!

Remember to answer a few before you ask ;)

Cheers.

I would go J-Mac, safest choice and highest ceiling  ;) the Bugg v Ellis v Morris is the same dilemma im facing aswell :-\

[elephants]

which 3 of: Shiel, Coniglio, J-Mac & Magner?

and

which 1 out of: Ellis, Morris & Bugg?

Cheers

After reading around FF and dt talk I am going with Bugg and the GWS boys :)

[auscoyote]

which 3 of: Shiel, Coniglio, J-Mac & Magner?

and

which 1 out of: Ellis, Morris & Bugg?

Cheers

After reading around FF and dt talk I am going with Bugg and the GWS boys :)

Yep I would too.

Now who would you start out of 5fer and Smedts in  Fwd line

[Zombie2.5]

Okay I'll generally answer everyone's questions here by listing the order of the best choices in each line in my opinion
Defenders: Bugg, Clarke, Ellis, Morris, Smedts

Mids: McDonald, Magner, Shiel, Greene, Coniglio

Rucks: Giles. That's it haha.

Forwards: D.Smith, Treloar, Cameron, Smedts. Wow just realised most popular fwd rooks are out this week.