Jack Redden?

[Scalabrine]

Hasn't been scoring well the last few weeks and I don't have a clue why? I got him in thinking he would have a bigger year this year but seems to be off to a slow start.

Does anyone have any points or reasons that might be the case of his poor scoring?

Should I trade or keep him?

Leave your suggestions below please! :)

[Scalabrine]

I can use my trades this week by going

Ledger > Treloar
and then
Redden > 580k mid?

Thoughts?

[BGK]

I think he's forgotten how to tackle. Hold onto him mate. If he turns into your worst mid by the end of the year, your still going ok.

[Scalabrine]

Yeah I will keep him then :) but if anything I will be waiting for my rookies to make more money before i decide to trade him

[Ringo]

His disposals are again letting him down this year.  personally I thought he would be the one to step up this year but to date has not shown a lot.  However in saying that and if he is your M6 an avearge of 90/100 will be great.  He may get that as Brisbanes run after the bye is very juicy compare to the pre bye draw.

[charliesheen]

He averaged 105 SC last year, so you were hedging your bets on him doing 115+.  Was always going to be a risky pick.  Not sure you want to go from one speculative semi-premium to another.  Downgrade him, and look to bring in another mid when they are on the cheap.  Sam Mitchell is an option in a few weeks.

[BigBob]

i went with him too but have just gone to stanton

[charliesheen]

His disposals are again letting him down this year.  personally I thought he would be the one to step up this year but to date has not shown a lot.  However in saying that and if he is your M6 an avearge of 90/100 will be great.  He may get that as Brisbanes run after the bye is very juicy compare to the pre bye draw.

90-100 average will not cut it as M6.  You need 115+ from all your mids.  I am not sure whats going on with Redden, but even his DT average has been very poor, so its not just disposal efficiency.

[BGK]

His disposals are again letting him down this year.  personally I thought he would be the one to step up this year but to date has not shown a lot.  However in saying that and if he is your M6 an avearge of 90/100 will be great.  He may get that as Brisbanes run after the bye is very juicy compare to the pre bye draw.

90-100 average will not cut it as M6.  You need 115+ from all your mids.  I am not sure whats going on with Redden, but even his DT average has been very poor, so its not just disposal efficiency.

Have a look at his stats. He was an elite tackler last year but he's dropped off heaps in this area so far.

[Scalabrine]

His breakeven is 120+ this week, should i trade him before his price drops?

[charliesheen]

Yes, bring Treloar.  Pfieffer/Miles can be used to fix Ledger if need be.  Be patient and wait for super premium to drop price.

[Scalabrine]

So, Redden > Treloar?

[Scalabrine]

I can do a straight swap for either
Redden > S Thompson
or
Redden > Rockliff
I may even consider Josh.P Kennedy?

[charliesheen]

Can post entire team and cash remaining?

[Scalabrine]