Ask Q: Fragile Friday (20/4/12)

[Justin Bieber]

I got fcking 10 out this week. Should I trade mummy?

10? Wow! Who isn't playing for you, and I thought Mummy was playing!?

Look at his tweets, Mummy late withdrawal http://twitter.com/#!/afl_pkeane/
and other teams updates :o

I saw  ;)

I'm sorta glad. Mummy has been flat so it's not a bad thing.

[Master Q]

Cripps for Stanley? thought Cripps was going to get more of the ball of half back...obviously not.

A little sideaways  :P

It'd try go Upgrade/Downgrade first but Stanley is a pretty good Plan B.

[Mr.Craig]

Yo Q. I'm in much the same position as others with multiple outs but I'll throw this one at you...

Milera or Kennedy on the ground?

I'm leaning towards Milera despite the possible sub risk. Can't see Kennedy getting much beyond 60 odd. Thoughts?

[Master Q]

Hey Q, cheers for this!

I am quite literally flowered for this round.

Backs: Shaw, Birchall, Smedts out.

Rucks: Mumford, Longer, Redden out.

So quite obviously I will cop two donuts if i don't trade. I didn't really want to trade this round seeing as I don't have fyfe, but it looks inevitable.

Thoughts on:

Shaw -> Waters/Conca/Someone else?
Mumford -> Sandi/Kreuzer

This will allow me to upgrade David Swallow to M. Murph next week.

Cheers buddy!

Birch?
Mummy to Sandi is a nice trade.

Yo Q. I'm in much the same position as others with multiple outs but I'll throw this one at you...

Milera or Kennedy on the ground?

I'm leaning towards Milera despite the possible sub risk. Can't see Kennedy getting much beyond 60 odd. Thoughts?

Milera against Freo (Bench time + possible sub) v Kennedy against Adelaide (A lot of time on ground)... Kennedy for me.

[TheAnt]

Theres a rumour that Birch hasn't travelled to Perth, although since Hawks dont train till 6PM perth time I don't think we'll find out before lockout.

[Mr.Craig]

Theres a rumour that Birch hasn't travelled to Perth, although since Hawks dont train till 6PM perth time I don't think we'll find out before lockout.

That's if we can get a report from training in time...

Or is there an FF spy that can be sent to Perth Airport maybe?

[pinochio]

1 of smith or kennedy on the ground?

[Master Q]

Theres a rumour that Birch hasn't travelled to Perth, although since Hawks dont train till 6PM perth time I don't think we'll find out before lockout.

That's if we can get a report from training in time...

Or is there an FF spy that can be sent to Perth Airport maybe?

Rumours that is  false  :P

1 of smith or kennedy on the ground?

Kennedy

[Master Q]

20 minutes left!

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

[matt1985]

20 minutes left!

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

Hey Q as with everyone else, got a few headaches this week! Who would you choose between Sandi and Cox for Mummy?

And the rumour of Birchell not travelling has me nervous also... I have Morris and Mohr on bench, who would you EMG out of those 2?

Thanks mate!

[essendon2]

Mumford --> Sandi/Kreuz?
&
Fyfe --> Sidebottom?

sound good?  ???

[henry]

Cheer for you :)

Who to start in the mids, 2 of caddy, magner and shiel

And in the fwds: 2 of a. Kennedy, Porplyzia, D. Smith, Treloar

Thanks.

[Master Q]

20 minutes left!

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

Hey Q as with everyone else, got a few headaches this week! Who would you choose between Sandi and Cox for Mummy?

And the rumour of Birchell not travelling has me nervous also... I have Morris and Mohr on bench, who would you EMG out of those 2?

Thanks mate!

Sandi.

Morris, but I expect Birch to play.

Mumford --> Sandi/Kreuz?
&
Fyfe --> Sidebottom?

sound good?  ???

Fill you face a donut if you don't trade Mummy... I'd stick with Fyfe if that's not the case.

[Master Q]

Cheer for you :)

Who to start in the mids, 2 of caddy, magner and shiel

And in the fwds: 2 of a. Kennedy, Porplyzia, D. Smith, Treloar

Thanks.

Caddy and Magner

Porps and Kennedy.

10 minutes left!

PS: Don't be afraid to cheer  ;)

[henry]

Thanks for that, you're up to 85  cheers now.