Ask Q: Fragile Friday (20/4/12)

[Master Q]

It's already Round 4, and trades ideas are getting mixed and matched every 30 seconds!  ;)

Like always, ask me a question, and I'll give you my honest opinion. Please do not answer any questions for me, if you want to start a discussion, start a thread!

If you'd like to thank me, don't be afraid to give me a cheer  ;)

Thread closes at 5:40 PM EST, I also have a team  ;)

Thanks
-Q!  ;)

[Justin Bieber]

I got fcking 10 out this week. Should I trade mummy?

[LF]

Best replacement for Mumford
And should I start Coniglio,Shiel or Old Mac

[Chopps]

thoughts on heater Q? keep or trade

[Justin Bieber]

Yeah also heater, fyfe and birchall. Thoughts on all....".....

[boschie12]

Is C. dempesy, playing!!! thought he done his hamstring?

[Master Q]

I got fcking 10 out this week. Should I trade mummy?

10? Wow! Who isn't playing for you, and I thought Mummy was playing!?

Best replacement for Mumford
And should I start Coniglio,Shiel or Old Mac

Sandi  :-X

Tough one... Old Mac?

thoughts on heater Q? keep or trade

Keep. Unless you need some more firepower and can afford some of the big boys...

[elephants]

Ellis or Morris

One of Shiel, McDonald and Coniglio

Cheers Q!

[Master Q]

Just found out about Mummy...

Yeah also heater, fyfe and birchall. Thoughts on all....".....

Keep,Keep,Keep.

I'm backing Fyfe and Birchall big time... Shaw is a bit of a 50/50. If you are missing one of the gun backs trade, if not, sit tight...

Is C. dempesy, playing!!! thought he done his hamstring?

According to the AFL site he is playing. Wait until final teams later tonight though.

[Zombie2.5]

Do you reckon Pendles/Boyd are better choices than Gazza for Capt this wk?(which one?)
Should I do Fyfe > Robbo, i reckon Fyfe's gonna be too risky with the shoulder and reinjuring himself, then just losing money and then having to end up trading him anyways.

Also how many players are you missing? (e.g. Shaw, Grimes, Lake, Goodes, Mummy and non playing rooks)
I luckily only have Shaw and Greene(and Smedts) missing.

North Melb to beat Sydney without the 'Goodes' and a Mummy?

[Master Q]

Ellis or Morris

One of Shiel, McDonald and Coniglio

Cheers Q!

Ellis and Old Mac - Although very hard to split all 3 as they are all unpredictable  :P

Do you reckon Pendles/Boyd are better choices than Gazza for Capt this wk?(which one?)
Should I do Fyfe > Robbo, i reckon Fyfe's gonna be too risky with the shoulder and reinjuring himself, then just losing money and then having to end up trading him anyways.

Also how many players are you missing? (e.g. Shaw, Grimes, Lake, Goodes, Mummy and non playing rooks)
I luckily only have Shaw and Greene(and Smedts) missing.

North Melb to beat Sydney without the 'Goodes' and a Mummy?

Go Gazza. Out of those 2 however, Boyd.

Hold Fyfe.

I have Shaw, Clay Smith, Burger (might be traded) and Smedts out.

Roos baby!

[Zombie2.5]

I got fcking 10 out this week. Should I trade mummy?

10? Wow! Who isn't playing for you, and I thought Mummy was playing!?

Look at his tweets, Mummy late withdrawal http://twitter.com/#!/afl_pkeane/
and other teams updates :o

[TheAnt]

Cripps for Stanley? thought Cripps was going to get more of the ball of half back...obviously not.

[Master Q]

I got fcking 10 out this week. Should I trade mummy?

10? Wow! Who isn't playing for you, and I thought Mummy was playing!?

Look at his tweets, Mummy late withdrawal http://twitter.com/#!/afl_pkeane/
and other teams updates :o

I saw  ;)

[tigers123]

Hey Q, cheers for this!

I am quite literally flowered for this round.

Backs: Shaw, Birchall, Smedts out.

Rucks: Mumford, Longer, Redden out.

So quite obviously I will cop two donuts if i don't trade. I didn't really want to trade this round seeing as I don't have fyfe, but it looks inevitable.

Thoughts on:

Shaw -> Waters/Conca/Someone else?
Mumford -> Sandi/Kreuzer

This will allow me to upgrade David Swallow to M. Murph next week.

Cheers buddy!