Poll for defenders

[rider]

I have not traded yet (so have itchy fingers), and i think if Shaw is out for two, and then is likely to drop another $30k and potentially have reoccurring soft tissue issues all season i should get rid of him. Am leaning towards conca and the money, though duffman might be a good option too.

Thoughts?

[BratPack]

None of them. Just bench him

[Colliwobblers]

None of them. Just bench him

this

[Justin Bieber]

Give him the flick, he's shower.

[13Brummy]

I traded him to Waters.  I probably would've gone Conca as well were it not for the byes.

[Justin Bieber]

I like how no one even thinks of getting the duffman ;D

[BratPack]

I like how no one even thinks of getting the duffman ;D

If I wanted a wildly inconsistent player with a floor of 20. I'd pick up Karmichael Hunt

[Justin Bieber]

I like how no one even thinks of getting the duffman ;D

If I wanted a wildly inconsistent player with a floor of 20. I'd pick up Karmichael Hunt

Inconsistent? More consistent than Broughton.

[rider]

one of the reasons i am thinking about getting the duffman.... already have broughton and there combined average may be quite palatable. a bit of a e/w bet...

[mezzoculo]

Hold onto him for now. Maybe a fortnight off will be just the tonic for his current sub-par form.

[kilbluff1985]

trade him now or you have to keep him

[mezzoculo]

trade him now or you have to keep him

Why? He won't lose any value not playing.