suggestions for round 4?

[dickitch]

Team shown below, is there any subbing or trades you'd do with the below based on teams this week

def: got no choice here really, unless I trade - question mark on dempsey, ellis looks to be an emerg
mid: not sure whether to put mcdonald on, but who to take off
rucks: no choice without trade, concerned about Giles role this round
fwd: too many choices, who to start with, how is fyfe gonna go - milera v hall v smith

[The Bomber]

start jmac ahead of shiel

didnt you have lake or shaw or goodes...lucky

[dickitch]

lucky on that account, but i did trade out Broughton (110) for Dempsey (6) - so i didn't come away unscathed

Put McDonald on over Shiels - no changes to forward line?

[BratPack]

JMac for Shiel


Trade Fyfe


As for the back dilema....Bring in Tomlinson maybe?

[The Bomber]

what back dilemma???

wouldnt change forward line IMO unless milera is given the green vest...

[dickitch]

Yeh i don't really have a back dilemma, only problem here is they're not great scorers and Dempsey question marks - but i think i'll hold off and save trades here.

Trade Fyfe?  hmmmm i know there's a LOT of talk about him, but he's been named to play and in usual role - he's gonna become cheaper but, well i dunno - tempted to swap him for Sidebum or Roughead for another ruck option, would do that today but have no dpp in ruck atm... i traded out broughton and got stung, will the same happen with fyfe