Murphy or Barlow?

[sinclair39]

Tossing up upgrading Tom Ledger to one of these blokes. I was leaning towards Barlow but that would give my 3 round 12 bye players in the Mid, while Murphy would give my 2 in round 12. Opinions?

[ubeaut]

Less risky going the Smurph. Unfortunately Carlton are looking good :( And Barlow has had one good year,whereas Murphy has been consistently good for years. Depends on what you could do with the 150 k though? I'd personally rather lock in a more than likely top 6 mid.

[roo boys!]

Go with Murphy. More reliable. Unless you really need the 150k like ubeaut said, Barlow isn't a bad option.

[Ringo]

Murphy for me and agree with Ubeaut unless the 150k being saved is being well used elsewhere in gaining a prem.  If that is the case then Barlow or Hayes are not bad options.

[HotTiges]

make Barlow your next upgrade, grab Murphy while you can.. guy's a superstar

[EZA100]

Definitly get murphy he is in top 5 to win brown low and then get barlow next round maybe because he is cheap but it isn't a easy choice