The Heath Shaw Thread

[tbagrocks]

Conca Conca Conca train entering the station, all aboard and make some money

[tor01doc]

If you want money - M Clarke is your man.

Also check bye issues. A lot could depend on who else you have back there.

Must have Goddard.

[gav139]

Not sure who to trade for, both been pretty consistent so far so I've got no idea who to pick. What are ppls thoughts?

[ando_10]

out of them id say carrazzo. but i think shaw will play anzac day buckley is trolling everyone but trade him

[gav139]

Yeah he could, but if it does end up being two or more, i dont think he has been scoring well enough for me to hold onto him. Any other backs you think are worth considering?

[BGK]

out of them id say carrazzo. but i think shaw will play anzac day buckley is trolling everyone but trade him

I keep wondering this myself. I feel like Shaw and Daisy are being rested.

Go with Carrots. He will have a good year IMO

[vtaced]

What about Broughton?

I haven't seen many fremantle games this year. Is he playing in the middle or a negative defensive role?

I know if he plays in the middle he will score 100+ most weeks and he is $50k cheaper than Shaw.

[thebrock]

Thinking of using the new trade rule in trading Shaw.

Thinking trading Shaw, subbing smedlts to the backline and NRoo in for Shaw

Backs: Goodard, Deledio, Shaw, Adcock, Malceski, Lake, Clarke (Morris, ellis)

Forwards: Franklin, PAV, Chappy, Goodes, JROO, A. Kennedy,  Trelor (smeldts, smith)

Thoughts???

I am considering the same but unsure, may just hold Shaw and cop one bad week to preserve trades.

[thebrock]

Conca Conca Conca train entering the station, all aboard and make some money

I am surprised no one has responded to this, if I trade I am more and more liking this option although I do feel it's get on Nroo now or never, depends how much you think he can average?

As for Conca was he sub/subbed first round? I can't recall scores  35, 84, 115. As long as that 35 was vest related I would be pretty comfortable going Conca as something a bit more unique than Clarke. Thoughts people?

[BGK]

Conca Conca Conca train entering the station, all aboard and make some money

I am surprised no one has responded to this, if I trade I am more and more liking this option although I do feel it's get on Nroo now or never, depends how much you think he can average?

As for Conca was he sub/subbed first round? I can't recall scores  35, 84, 115. As long as that 35 was vest related I would be pretty comfortable going Conca as something a bit more unique than Clarke. Thoughts people?

He was the sub rd 1. The only problem with Conca is rd 13.

[fever]

couldn't see another heath thread discussing his replacement (at least in the titles i skimmed on page 1).

who do we like? atm i'm  tossing up between carazzo, scotland, bock and suckling, but i've thrown out some other names worthy of thought.

[vtaced]

i would definitely go scotland if you can afford him. I already have him, so I was thinking broughton. slow start to the season yes...but i have a feeling he will improve, especially if he plays in the middle.

[kilbluff1985]

lol look at the 4th thread above this one

[Torress]

i've got some issues down back this week and i'm unfortunately looking at shifting heater on as well  :'(

how inconsistent is this guy!!! i feel if i keep and he is out for the 2 weeks combined with the other outs this week, and the fact i'll cop a doughnut by keeping him i'm off loading. for the sake of keeping me in it overall i feel as if i need to. feels like a waste but zeros can't occur.

but who would you replace him for? i feel i'm gonna ponder this right til lockout! i picked adcock, just that he is 60k cheaper than scotland, fisher. and also a different bye to birch/carrots/fisher/scotland. also simon black is out with a broken hand and i reckon adcock will push up the ground whilst he is out, which can't hurt. 

[spasticnut]

I am tradinh Heater. I can get anyone I want but I dont want to get Scotland because I want to have some extra money in the bank. Then I was tossing up between Carrazzo and Adcock. I am leaning towards Acock. What do you's think?