The Heath Shaw Thread

[joreo12]

yeah i don't think i can have lids, ellis morris and conca in the same team as well as cotchin and martin

[Bones Bombers]

He may only miss the Port game and still play Anzac Day against Essendon.
Could be playing tricks!
His price won't change, only the player you want to trade to may change?

[tigers123]

seeing as i don't have fyfe i'll probably oust shaw for waters given my only bench cover is ellis, morris and smedts...

[Justin Bieber]

I'm trading him. I can't hold onto a prem for 2 weeks.... flower this.

exactly

dont reckon he will be in top 7 defenders come end of season

liking the look of conca

Yeah me two, but as said I have have Ellis, Morris and Lids.

I can get Carrots, but that makes 4 prem defenders....

[joreo12]

thinking i may get carazzo

[the raven]

The ironic thing is, Shaw was meant to be my semi-unique premium player. I was thinking that not many top 1000 teams would take him as he was always a risk. Also annoying that I have chosen him over adcock and broughton, who have at least both shown something so far.

[Jalapeno]

Get on he duff. I think he will be a solid pick ;)

[Justin Bieber]

Shaw was doing shower and now he's out for two weeks. So I'm probably going to get rid of him. The best choice who I can afford is Carrots, who is the rd 13 bye player. I already have God, lids and Birch :-* lol.

So that makes 4 prem rd 13 meaning 2 definite donuts. My question: Is it worth getting another Rd 13 player (since there the only good players) or get someone like Waters who has been going above average or the Duffman who didn't gain value which is good ;D.

Thoughts people. No poll, cause I don't believe in polls.

[tigers123]

He may only miss the Port game and still play Anzac Day against Essendon.
Could be playing tricks!
His price won't change, only the player you want to trade to may change?

i'd say that's highly doubtful, they'd be wanting to make essendon worried he's coming back... the article clearly says two weeks, and knowing someone like shaw this injury could get drawn out for months!

[the raven]

Also, with shaw being the round 12 bye player i picked, there are no other replacements that tempt me from round 11/12. As I already have 3 round 13 premiums it would be suicide to bring in a rd 12 player (carazzo, scotland, suckling).

Any suggestions other than adcock and broughton?

[jason2889]

Would it be ok to have Broughton and Duffman in the same team? Only thing i can really think of doing at the moment, don't trust Hurn to keep doing what he has

[LF]

Waters if you don't already have him
Malceski

[tigers123]

hmmm im in the same boat as you and was thinking waters.... however i can't really be flowered with the byes, if i can get someone that averages above what waters can get every week the donut will probs balance itself out over the course of the year... so for me its between waters, conca and carazzo at the moment...

[Justin Bieber]

Or Duffman. I like the fuzz.

[joreo12]

my team stands at this do people think i should be trading? if i don't this week i have a zero

Defence- Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Heppell, lake, morris, bugg, (ellis), (smedts)
Mid- Ablett, Boyd, Pendles, Cotchin, Magner, Greene, (conigilio), (shiel)
Rucks- Cox, giles, (redden), (stephenson)
Forwards- Franklin, S.Johnson, Fyfe, Martin, Dangerfield, D.Smith, Kennedy, (hall), (Kerridge)

I'm keen on stanley but thats only if fyfe is out, thoughts would be appreciated