The Heath Shaw Thread

Started by Hiro, April 17, 2012, 11:21:50 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to get

Waters
10 (12%)
Broughton
3 (3.6%)
Hargrave
2 (2.4%)
Adcock
4 (4.8%)
Carrazo cause your a lucky flowerer and you can afford him
7 (8.4%)
Bugg?
4 (4.8%)
Houli
1 (1.2%)
Malceski
4 (4.8%)
Heppel
2 (2.4%)
Birch
4 (4.8%)
Suckling
2 (2.4%)
Fisher
0 (0%)
Other (Please Specify)
1 (1.2%)
Rookie
3 (3.6%)
Not Trading
24 (28.9%)
Didnt take him cause I can predict the future. Just kidding im just not a moron
5 (6%)
Duffman
7 (8.4%)

Total Members Voted: 6

The F.A.R.K.

#30
if he is out for 2 thats the end of the line for me

options are

Reece Conca (two very very good scores and one sub affected score)
Beau Waters (has had a very easy fixture so far)
Andrew Carrazo (he will have some bad ones thru tagging)
Dyson Heppell (has been a bit down on last year)
Marty Clarke (will take shaws role, surely he is in red hot form)

at the moment im leaning towards clarke and conca

joreo12

Latest on Heath Shaw is he's out for two weeks? do i hang on to him, or trade? if i don't trade somewhere in my backline this week i have a zero. What do people think?

BarnDogg

Do you have cover(if so who)? How many trades have you used?

Praetorian

I'd take Waters or Carrazzo out of those. They're the only two I think will be in the top 7 come year's end.

The F.A.R.K.

ive used two

im not really fussed about trades

i only have minimal rookies on field so minimal trades needed there

back : bugg
mid: smith, magner, Greene
ruck: giles (keeper)
fwd : kennedy

so 5 trades there for upgrade/downgrade plu lets say i trade everyone on bench out at some point so that 13 trades used plus 2 already done so 15. Leaves me 9 to play around with injuries, upgrades, sideways trades ect

only have danger and hargrave as mid pricers and i reckon danger will be a keeper so lets say 8 trades for injury ect

rest of my team is premkium and keepers

jaffa35

I bet you'll find both Shaw and Daisy playing on Anzac day as their injuries are only supposedly "minor"

BarnDogg

If you can cover with Ellis or Morris I would hold.

They are good for 65-75ish.

The F.A.R.K.

id rather cut my losses on shaw

i reckon marty clarke has taken his half back role and shaw is stuck tagging in back pocket

and pies are on decline reckon he might end up with below 80 av

owenbond007


Doyle

Link?

Edit: Nvm, just saw it on the AFL site

BarnDogg

I think you are being a bit melodramatic there. Shaw did get 81 last week!

All the players you would be trading to are only going to average around 80-85ish anyway. Ellis will get you a 65-75, I think you should save the trade, it's only two weeks, this is what your bench players are for!

GoLions

well he's out for 2 weeks now....

joreo12


joreo12

I thinking if Fyfe has surgery Fyfe~ Stanley and Lake to Scotland/Carazzo and then leaving shaw on the bench for two weeks

Windigo

Leaning toward a Fyfe trade to Cloke.

Will see the teams, but latest info isn't good.