Which two start in M5 and M6?

[esquire]

Just looking for opinions on this one if you don't mind.

I need to pick two of the four available.

Basing my decision purely on the averages available at this point is it prudent to start Magner and Old Mac and leave Caddy and Shiel on the bench? Caddy has been consistent (-ish), Shiel has improved every game but only reached Caddy's average last game, where as Magner has fluctuated and McDonald has played just the once...

Cheers

[Justin Bieber]

Trade caddy and get some dough left over $$$

[esquire]

Trade caddy and get some dough left over $$$

Thanks whatlez. Was planning to trade Caddy when Neale/Zorko look like being options. Who to start of those 4 is my main query atm.

[Justin Bieber]

Trade caddy and get some dough left over $$$

Thanks whatlez. Was planning to trade Caddy when Neale/Zorko look like being options. Who to start of those 4 is my main query atm.

I say get caddy out ASAP. But if you don't, play him and magner,

[esquire]

Trade caddy and get some dough left over $$$

Thanks whatlez. Was planning to trade Caddy when Neale/Zorko look like being options. Who to start of those 4 is my main query atm.

I say get caddy out ASAP. But if you don't, play him and magner,

Or I was thinking to use him as a springboard to Murphy or Mitchell etc in a couple of weeks when I cull Shiel or Devon Smith/Milera/A. Kennedy from my fwds.

[GoLions]

Eenee meenee minee mo. On it.

[Justin Bieber]

Trade caddy and get some dough left over $$$

Thanks whatlez. Was planning to trade Caddy when Neale/Zorko look like being options. Who to start of those 4 is my main query atm.

I say get caddy out ASAP. But if you don't, play him and magner,

Or I was thinking to use him as a springboard to Murphy or Mitchell etc in a couple of weeks when I cull Shiel or Devon Smith/Milera/A. Kennedy from my fwds.

Well that sounds good.

[TheHanger]

We jumped on Caddy when we should have grabbed Gaff...darn

Keep him till he maxes out don't use up a trade he will get a bit better hopefully getting 80s

[esquire]

We jumped on Caddy when we should have grabbed Gaff...darn

Keep him till he maxes out don't use up a trade he will get a bit better hopefully getting 80s

Gaff or Masten... Every year there's one player that I get caught up in the hype with. This year Caddy got me.

[HappyDEZ]

Magner & McDonald are the logical choices IMO.

[Zombie2.5]

I'd say Magner and then roll a dice/flip a coin and take your pick from the last 3.

How bout for me: Magner, Shiel, Coniglio and Greene?
I started Magner and Greene(obviously) last week and turns out Shiel and Cogs outscored both.  :-\
I'm thinking still stick with Magma and Greene but what are your opinions on this relevant topic ;)?

[HappyDEZ]

I would go Magner & Shiel & hope Magner returns to his better scores & Shiel continues his improvement. I know efficiency counts alot in SC & he only had 1 mark but he did get 28 touches, was the leading con poss player on the ground with 15 & the leading clearance player on the field with 9. The SC gods a bit harsh with 79?

[Zombie2.5]

I would go Magner & Shiel & hope Magner returns to his better scores & Shiel continues his improvement. I know efficiency counts alot in SC & he only had 1 mark but he did get 28 touches, was the leading con poss player on the ground with 15 & the leading clearance player on the field with 9. The SC gods a bit harsh with 79?

What thE? ???
Shiely got 28 touches??? thats pretty gun, just checked stats he got more handballs and he didnt get much points from anything else(e.g. tackles, marks) hence the low scores and we're talking bout DT here ;)
Anyways thanks for the help. Anyone else?