Who's starting J Mac this week?

[GoLions]

If there is anything I've learnt from watching giants last 2 weeks it's the senior guys - Palmer, ward, scully - seem to know where to run to get the ball more often.

For this reason, jmac is straight back on field for me. Shiel/Greene on bench. No doubt they will score more!

After 2 weeks off he will be lacking match fitness ..

Well he scored well in round 1, and technically that is with zero match fitness.

[Football Factory]

If there is anything I've learnt from watching giants last 2 weeks it's the senior guys - Palmer, ward, scully - seem to know where to run to get the ball more often.

For this reason, jmac is straight back on field for me. Shiel/Greene on bench. No doubt they will score more!

After 2 weeks off he will be lacking match fitness ..

Well he scored well in round 1, and technically that is with zero match fitness.

yeah no one had match fitness round 1  ;D

[GoLions]

If there is anything I've learnt from watching giants last 2 weeks it's the senior guys - Palmer, ward, scully - seem to know where to run to get the ball more often.

For this reason, jmac is straight back on field for me. Shiel/Greene on bench. No doubt they will score more!

After 2 weeks off he will be lacking match fitness ..

Well he scored well in round 1, and technically that is with zero match fitness.

yeah no one had match fitness round 1  ;D

If you don't think he will do well, then don't play him. I for one think that as one of the more experienced players in the GWS side he will score quite well. At least 80+ i think, which is great from a rookie priced player.

[Football Factory]

If there is anything I've learnt from watching giants last 2 weeks it's the senior guys - Palmer, ward, scully - seem to know where to run to get the ball more often.

For this reason, jmac is straight back on field for me. Shiel/Greene on bench. No doubt they will score more!

After 2 weeks off he will be lacking match fitness ..

Well he scored well in round 1, and technically that is with zero match fitness.

yeah no one had match fitness round 1  ;D

If you don't think he will do well, then don't play him. I for one think that as one of the more experienced players in the GWS side he will score quite well. At least 80+ i think, which is great from a rookie priced player.

Im going to play Magner because he is more match fit ..  but Macca could score well also .. flip a coin   ;)

[GoLions]

If there is anything I've learnt from watching giants last 2 weeks it's the senior guys - Palmer, ward, scully - seem to know where to run to get the ball more often.

For this reason, jmac is straight back on field for me. Shiel/Greene on bench. No doubt they will score more!

After 2 weeks off he will be lacking match fitness ..

Well he scored well in round 1, and technically that is with zero match fitness.

yeah no one had match fitness round 1  ;D

If you don't think he will do well, then don't play him. I for one think that as one of the more experienced players in the GWS side he will score quite well. At least 80+ i think, which is great from a rookie priced player.

Im going to play Magner because he is more match fit ..  but Macca could score well also .. flip a coin    ;)

Nah need something with 4 sides, anyone have a triangular pyramid? I'm pretty sure they have 4 sides  :P

[specky lecky]

So he's back this week??? Sweet!!!! if he's named, I'm playing him!!!! Shiel out junior mac in

[underdog11]

dont doubt the magnet i remeber barlow got 46 in his third score

[Jukes]

If Mac does good this week (80+) and Coniglio doesn't beat him I'm going Coniglio->MacDonald, hoping for a 150k gain there and I can use that to upgrade Shaw to Scotland.

I see what you're doing here with these trades (trying to eliminate your weaknesses early) but the Shaw to Scotland trade is mental...

You'll regret it come both bye time and finals time.

I don't see Shaw as really a weakness, he'll be very good for the rest of the season. Just Scotland and Carlton are in beautiful form and there aren't that many other places I can use that 150k.

[Ricochet]

Have to start 3 of Jmac, Magner, C.smith, Conigs and Shiel.
And Jmac is definitely starting

[Madsnake]

Jmac/Shiel + Magner for me

[henry]

I probably won't start him, most likely because I don't have him.

[Memphistopheles]

McDonald and Magner to start for me.

Possibly Shiel as well depending on how the Fyfe situation pans out.

[hardnut]

McMagner combo for me, Sheil and C.Smith can cover the bench for me

[Lucastorm]

Woohoo Jmac is back!

I still think I'll field Magner - rekon he will bounce back hard after last game

[Zombie2.5]

I probably won't start him, most likely because I don't have him.

hehe same here.

I have: Magner, Shiel, Greene and Coniglio and im thinking Magner + Greene but not so sure, last week Shiel and Cogs outscored em warming the bench. But im sure they'll bounce back, what do you guys think though?