The Nathan Fyfe Thread

[Alka]

That option has only been able to pick recently....

And it's steadily increasing in popularity. I'd say at least 50% of people will stick if he is named, myself included. He played with a bad shoulder all last season and it didn't slow him down.  There's also no great option for me, already having Robbo, the rest are just as risky. I hope he gets trade out a lot actually, would love him to become more unique.

[glam77]

What are people thoughts on something like...

Fyfe to Treolar

... and in 2 weeks time

mid-rookie to Pendles

EDIT.... oops, just found a whole section where people discussed Treloar as an option

[Justin Bieber]

That option has only been able to pick recently....

And it's steadily increasing in popularity. I'd say at least 50% of people will stick if he is named, myself included. He played with a bad shoulder all last season and it didn't slow him down.  There's also no great option for me, already having Robbo, the rest are just as risky. I hope he gets trade out a lot actually, would love him to become more unique.

Yeah I'm saying that if that was on the poll from the start it would be probably winning the poll.

[Praetorian]

Apologies for another Fyfe thread, but there's been some suggestion in the 'official' Fyfe thread that opinions have changed since it was created. This is a simple yes/no for whether you're going to trade him or not.

Also note that I've left it open for you to change your vote, since I imagine some opinions might be swayed by the release of the teams tonight. :P

[Justin Bieber]

I don't like when people make poll where I can't view the results without voting  :-\

I see it is unique to trade him. But keeping him saves a trade, but I REALLy want my main man Robbo. So it's going to tough and I will be sitting on the computer till 1 min until lockout :o

[13Brummy]

im trading him to robbo regardless of whether he plays... that 22 will stick with his price drop for the next 2 rounds so he'll drop to around 400k by then.  plus if he re-does his shoulder his price will drop further and he will be out for a long time.  the way i see it is that he is most likely to do it again which will waste a trade anyway so why not avoid his price drop

[Windigo]

If a premium is scoring tons or near to it, who cares if they lose money.

[Seano14]

My tactic this yr is purely guns and rookies.  With the exception of Pfiefer everyone is playing and well.   I think a downward fyfe trade (currently FWD) would enable me to have 6 premo's in the midfield by rd 8 (420k currenty in bank).  I'm thinking nat is a sunk cost, if you can get to rnd 8 with a 1-4 or 2-3 win loss ratio rookies are primed to smash the upgrade.

[Praetorian]

I don't like when people make poll where I can't view the results without voting  :-\

That's to encourage you to vote, as well as not letting other people's answers influence yours. ;) Besides, you can always change it afterwards.

See, I'm personally still undecided but voted that I will be hanging on to him, because at this stage that's what I plan to do. Nowhere near 100%, though.

[Praetorian]

If a premium is scoring tons or near to it, who cares if they lose money.

No-one, but that's not the point. If he scores 70 this week before getting subbed off, his price will plummet to like, 400k. For a lot of people, that's going to make trading him out next week for someone they want completely unfeasible.

[tbagrocks]

in two games when he's 380k, I jump on! good bye motlop, hello 100+

[The F.A.R.K.]

if you keep him and he tears up its a win, because a lot will trade him out

if you ttrade him and he tears up it doesnt matter coz lots have

if you trade him and he does shower its a win

tbh if you dont think he will av 90+ for overall year trade him, if you think he will keep him

[ossie85]

yes/no polls are kind of crazy.

You are either LITERALLY asking people to make a decision for you. What's the point in playing if that's the case? Or, it is a very boring 2 option poll.

[Tom_16]

yes/no polls are kind of crazy.

You are either LITERALLY asking people to make a decision for you. What's the point in playing if that's the case? Or, it is a very boring 2 option poll.

I like yes/no polls. Isn't the whole idea of this type of sites to discuss trade options/players and see what other people think of them so you can get an informed opinion? Please stop deleting the yes/no polls surrounding fyfe as i'm sure the majority of member here appreciate them, if they don't like them they don't have to vote on them.

[ossie85]

yes/no polls are kind of crazy.

You are either LITERALLY asking people to make a decision for you. What's the point in playing if that's the case? Or, it is a very boring 2 option poll.

I like yes/no polls. Isn't the whole idea of this type of sites to discuss trade options/players and see what other people think of them so you can get an informed opinion? Please stop deleting the yes/no polls surrounding fyfe as i'm sure the majority of member here appreciate them, if they don't like them they don't have to vote on them.

I 100% agree that this site is to discuss trade options/players.

But I don't think saying 'yes' or 'no' is a discussion. A discussion on Nat Fyfe is the 26 pages of Fyfe related material in this thread.

A lot of members here (myself included) are tired of the thousands of Fyfe threads created.