The Nathan Fyfe Thread

[Football Factory]

Shoulders are the worst sort of injury .. not a quick fix .. give me a hammy any day of the week

I think his shoulder will get a good test vs the saints  ;)

[The Grundles]

http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/newsId/133454/Default.aspx

BOOM!

[Justin Bieber]

http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/newsId/133454/Default.aspx

BOOM!

He mentioned this in the first post ???

[Football Factory]

http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/newsId/133454/Default.aspx

BOOM!

He mentioned this in the first post ???

;D

[Football Factory]

Should we keep him. Make a poll.

        ???

The Best Option?
Johnson    - 13 (4.9%)
Chapman    - 21 (8%)
Cloke    - 10 (3.8%)
Pavlich    - 9 (3.4%)
Robinson    - 70 (26.6%)
Rioli    - 4 (1.5%)
Adams    - 3 (1.1%)
Cornes    - 8 (3%)
Riewoldt    - 15 (5.7%)
Gray    - 6 (2.3%)
Sidebottom    - 24 (9.1%)
Goodes    - 18 (6.8%)
Zaharakis    - 7 (2.7%)
O'Keefe    - 1 (0.4%)
Giansiracusa    - 4 (1.5%)
Lewis    - 5 (1.9%)
Whitecross    - 27 (10.3%)
Harvey    - 3 (1.1%)
Ballantyne    - 5 (1.9%)
Waite    - 1 (0.4%)
Hawkins    - 0 (0%)
I'm Keeping Fyfe    - 9 (3.4%)
   
Total Members Voted: 263

[Justin Bieber]

Should we keep him. Make a poll.

        ???

The Best Option?
Johnson    - 13 (4.9%)
Chapman    - 21 (8%)
Cloke    - 10 (3.8%)
Pavlich    - 9 (3.4%)
Robinson    - 70 (26.6%)
Rioli    - 4 (1.5%)
Adams    - 3 (1.1%)
Cornes    - 8 (3%)
Riewoldt    - 15 (5.7%)
Gray    - 6 (2.3%)
Sidebottom    - 24 (9.1%)
Goodes    - 18 (6.8%)
Zaharakis    - 7 (2.7%)
O'Keefe    - 1 (0.4%)
Giansiracusa    - 4 (1.5%)
Lewis    - 5 (1.9%)
Whitecross    - 27 (10.3%)
Harvey    - 3 (1.1%)
Ballantyne    - 5 (1.9%)
Waite    - 1 (0.4%)
Hawkins    - 0 (0%)
I'm Keeping Fyfe    - 9 (3.4%)
   
Total Members Voted: 263

Reset then?

[Lucastorm]

'IF' he gets the final approval from the surgeon.

And, shoulders... geeze the more you dislocate em the more likely they are to dislocate again...

Risky, but am willing to wait another round to see more premos go down in $$ and how Didz goes if he plays R5.

[Lucastorm]

I still don't know who I'd be happy replacing him with since I already have robbo and sidebum... So I'm hoping he comes good so I don't have to make another tough choice....

Any suggestions?

[Spite]

I still don't know who I'd be happy replacing him with since I already have robbo and sidebum... So I'm hoping he comes good so I don't have to make another tough choice....

Any suggestions?

Whitecross.

why risk it, he will drop heaps of money, in 3 weeks if he is still toning up i will turn a cash cow into him, i know it is 2 trades to get the same player in but it could make me money and sidebum and harvey are playing well

1 trade fyfe to robbo. 1 trade 3 rounds later smith to fyfe if sub. Total of 2 trades.

0 trades to keep fyfe. 1 trade to downgrade kennedy. 1 trade to get robbo. Total of 2 trades

First option has a reliable downgrade option in treloar. Who knows the second options downgrade option.

I wouldn't say it is a terrible move, I still think it is a 50/50 call.

I am banking on fyfe being the red vest, so I will trade him out this week.

[KruZin]

3.4% ?  ???

Have 96.6% of the FF DT community lost the plot?  :o

[Spite]

3.4% ?  ???

Have 96.6% of the FF DT community lost the plot?  :o

No, only 3.4% have.

Come on, it is a bit early to tell if trading him is the right thing to do or not!

[KruZin]

3.4% ?  ???

Have 96.6% of the FF DT community lost the plot?  :o

No, only 3.4% have.

Come on, it is a bit early to tell if trading him is the right thing to do or not!

I think it's a bit early for 96.4% to vote to trade him out before the teams are even named. He'll more than likely come good right away, just like he did twice last year.

He got through todays training with no probs and feels fine. As per the article in the HUN this arvo. Short of the second opinion that their getting tomorrow says he should get it operated on again, I can't see him missing. Why would they operate on it again if there has been no further long term damage done anyway?

[Perthwildcat]

It's just a dislocation, Mel Gibson did it all the time in Lethal Weapon...

Another guy named Judd plays okay with a dodgy shoulder.

[mpollock]

A lot of people didn't vote because they would be using a DPP link trade and there was not option to trade in a midfielder.

I am thinking Fyfe to Judd ... but still undecided ... hoping for some clearer information on if he will play ... if he will be subbed ... if he will be named on an extended bench .. what the 2nd opinon specialist says ... etc

He may have surgery still and then the decision is made for most unless you hold him till a S.Johnson for example bottoms out.

[Spite]

3.4% ?  ???

Have 96.6% of the FF DT community lost the plot?  :o

No, only 3.4% have.

Come on, it is a bit early to tell if trading him is the right thing to do or not!

I think it's a bit early for 96.4% to vote to trade him out before the teams are even named. He'll more than likely come good right away, just like he did twice last year.

He got through todays training with no probs and feels fine. As per the article in the HUN this arvo. Short of the second opinion that their getting tomorrow says he should get it operated on again, I can't see him missing. Why would they operate on it again if there has been no further long term damage done anyway?

I understand what you are saying, but it matters not if he plays this week for me and most of the 96.4% of people on FF. If he plays, we think he will be the sub, red or green OR he will score badly from now on OR he will drop so much value that we can get him out now and get something for him etc

As I said before, it is a bit early to make a call however what I do know, is that there is less risk associated with getting rid of him right now, which I think 96.4% of FF people agree on.