The Nathan Fyfe Thread

Started by Windigo, April 15, 2012, 10:10:35 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

The Best Option?

Robinson
Riewoldt
Sidebottom
Whitecross
Chapman
I'm Keeping Fyfe

Talisman

I reckon with Ball out, Sidebottom should see even more mid time, so I reckon if you're going for a straight swap, Fyfe -> Sidey works nicely.

However, as I didn't start with GAJ (will never know why!), I'll be most likely going:
1. Fyfe ---> Treloar, &
2. McCarthy ---> GAJ.

How does this sound?

Windigo

Seems solid.

Any other player than GAJ and I'd say no....But it as Ablett. Get him in.  ;)

Also, yes Sidey would be a great pickup. But I think a lot of people already have him, me included.

TMurphBROWNLOW


Holz

Quote from: Windigo on April 15, 2012, 10:26:14 AM
Surely everyone has D-Mart and Franklin. Can you afford to have 3 out in that bye round?  ???

If Adams get's a ton today against Geelong, then he'll be in.

yes you can, i have lewis,buddy and martin and im still going to pick up robinson. I always intended to get 4 round 13 forward premiums so might as well do it now.

LF

i`m going Fyfe to Whitecross if i can afford to because i only have Robbo.Lewis and Hall as my round 13 bye forwards.

jfitty


Legen...DARY


Torress

don't do DT but in SC i'll be bringing in buddy for fyfe.

so hang on, do we have a diagnosis on fyfe yet? out for season? he injured a shoulder last year, i didn't pick him up because of it and he played on and dominated. if he is out i'm bloody glad i hung onto broughts

mmurphy3


Windigo

Yeah, not getting Adams anymore.  :P


Windigo

Is Whitecross the real deal?

Solid pre-season scores, slayed 3 tons in a row and looks great.

Also, is he playing in Hodge's spot?

Ricochet

Quote from: Windigo on April 15, 2012, 07:45:10 PM
Is Whitecross the real deal?

Solid pre-season scores, slayed 3 tons in a row and looks great.

Also, is he playing in Hodge's spot?

He's definitely in my top 2 replacements for Fyfe.

ABC commentators said he was a tagger but "has developed into a real offensive weapon for the Hawks"

Not sure on his JS with Hodge out tho

elephants

Trying to be different here and considering Fyfe to Selwood and a midfield rookie (Shiel or Coniglio or Magnet or McDonald) to Treloar.

Is this dumb?? Is unique not so great here??
If I don't do this I will look at Chappy and Adams.

TMurphBROWNLOW

Quote from: Ricochet on April 15, 2012, 07:48:08 PM
Quote from: Windigo on April 15, 2012, 07:45:10 PM
Is Whitecross the real deal?

Solid pre-season scores, slayed 3 tons in a row and looks great.

Also, is he playing in Hodge's spot?

He's definitely in my top 2 replacements for Fyfe.

ABC commentators said he was a tagger but "has developed into a real offensive weapon for the Hawks"

Not sure on his JS with Hodge out tho

his JS with Hodge in is absolutely safe as nails. he has definitely cemented his spot in the best 22!

Phasir

sub him into the mids via a dpp rookie then trade to the Ziebster? 8)