The Nathan Fyfe Thread

Started by Slammer, April 14, 2012, 07:26:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who to come in for fyfe? (please no hate, i know there are many fyfe polls but please vote)

n.reiwoldt
17 (12.5%)
Sidebottom
28 (20.6%)
Cloke
7 (5.1%)
Chapman
4 (2.9%)
Blair
3 (2.2%)
Cyril
1 (0.7%)
Pav
5 (3.7%)
Whitecross
13 (9.6%)
Cornes
4 (2.9%)
Tippett
11 (8.1%)
selwood (would require ledger-->treloar)
10 (7.4%)
ward (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
hayes (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
barlow (would require ledger-->treloar)
8 (5.9%)
masten (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
Montagna (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
Ziebell (would require ledger-->treloar)
7 (5.1%)
carazzo (would require moving smedts forward)
6 (4.4%)
birchall (would require moving smedts forward)
2 (1.5%)
bock (would require moving smedts forward)
4 (2.9%)

Total Members Voted: 8

FonFatty

Quote from: vossy12 on April 20, 2012, 07:33:47 PM
who should i get please help??? i only got 10 mins of internet, fyfe to who?

i already got franklin, cloke, martin, dangerfield,
Jordan Lewis

The Bomber

pavlich...without fyfe he should push up into midfield

bluedreamin

DTTalk just tweeted Fyfe is late withdrawal...

ubeaut

Quote from: vossy12 on April 20, 2012, 07:33:47 PM
who should i get please help??? i only got 10 mins of internet, fyfe to who?

i already got franklin, cloke, martin, dangerfield,
I'd get Sidebum. Maybe Boomer harvey if you have the cash,but Sideys great value. Not sure whether to do this myself or wait a week and re-assess. ANYONE got any info? Out for season? surgery? back next week? please?

ubeaut

Quote from: The Bomber on April 20, 2012, 07:38:12 PM
pavlich...without fyfe he should push up into midfield
Pav will stay forward. Broughton,Mzungu,Hill,Crowley,Barlow,Mundy, etc they've got enough mids. When Mundy and Barlow were out Pav stayed FWD for the most part. Why would that change now?

vossy12

why sidebottom? maybe riewoldt?

The Bomber

because he has already started pushing up the field...he has had stints there this year already even though is kinda a "key forward" now...without fyfe his chances are even greater IMO...i may be wrong or a genius

bluedreamin

Glad they pulled the pin now and not half way through the game ... saved us another price drop at least.

HotTiges

Quote from: ubeaut on April 20, 2012, 07:40:32 PM
Quote from: vossy12 on April 20, 2012, 07:33:47 PM
who should i get please help??? i only got 10 mins of internet, fyfe to who?

i already got franklin, cloke, martin, dangerfield,
I'd get Sidebum. Maybe Boomer harvey if you have the cash,but Sideys great value. Not sure whether to do this myself or wait a week and re-assess. ANYONE got any info? Out for season? surgery? back next week? please?

fox sports news this morning said on that little popup that shoulder surgery was "inevitable"

FonFatty

Keeping him for this week, at least he wont lose money. Devon Smith will get a guernsey this week.
Next week I will pull the Ledger/C Smith --> Treloar & Fyfe --> Jelwood trade.

Hally85

do i go for j.kennedy or s.selwood in the MID

or

N.riewoldt in the FWD

brownmans muffins

Loving my perfect hindsight
Reversed the fyfe-nroo trade after he lasted the late lists
Copping donut
Kicking self more than I want to kick lyon

The F.A.R.K.


SkyWatcher

#328
ey mate, i was just wondering who you ended up trading in for Fyfe? I was able togo Fyfe > Murphy.

Im hoping outta your three options you went Josh Kennedy. I dont think Scott Selwood will score very well this week, i rkn he will be given the shut down role on Sam Mitchel even tho it wont matter to much with his break-even being minus something. Also Barlow wouldnt of been a bad option. Best of luck.

jamesalex

This morning's Herald Sun reports Fyfe to miss up to three weeks OR will go for surgery.

Happy I traded him out.