The Nathan Fyfe Thread

Started by Slammer, April 14, 2012, 07:26:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who to come in for fyfe? (please no hate, i know there are many fyfe polls but please vote)

n.reiwoldt
17 (12.5%)
Sidebottom
28 (20.6%)
Cloke
7 (5.1%)
Chapman
4 (2.9%)
Blair
3 (2.2%)
Cyril
1 (0.7%)
Pav
5 (3.7%)
Whitecross
13 (9.6%)
Cornes
4 (2.9%)
Tippett
11 (8.1%)
selwood (would require ledger-->treloar)
10 (7.4%)
ward (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
hayes (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
barlow (would require ledger-->treloar)
8 (5.9%)
masten (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
Montagna (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
Ziebell (would require ledger-->treloar)
7 (5.1%)
carazzo (would require moving smedts forward)
6 (4.4%)
birchall (would require moving smedts forward)
2 (1.5%)
bock (would require moving smedts forward)
4 (2.9%)

Total Members Voted: 8

coolfugitiv0

Quote from: Ringo on April 15, 2012, 10:15:13 PM
Quote from: oldshepp on April 15, 2012, 10:06:18 PM
Hayes or Barlow in the mids?

They will be my M5
I am also looking at Ziebell as an alternative at around the same price.
+1
JZ would have been in a lot of teams if he wasn't suspended.

motreck

whitecross + 100k?
averaging 110 but thought he has looked really good as well watching the hawks games

Babylove

I'm tossing up between two options. The first is straight swap from Fyfe to Whitecross.  The second is switching Fyfe into my midfield for Kennedy from GWS and bringing Scott Selwood into my Midfield. Would love some thoughts on this.

Colliwobblers

i got S Selwood last week and ill get whitecross this week if fyfe is going under the knife so take your pick, stright swap fyfe to whitecross is the smartest option however as your rook hasnt finished fattening up yet

but then if s selwood scores 100+ he will go up again next week another $50K

ArthurDent


Shiri

I'm thinkin' about moving him into the midfield and bringing in Matt Rosa as something unique. Not sold on Whitecross.

I've also got to worry about Lake and Dempsey

SkyWatcher

Quote from: Babylove on April 16, 2012, 12:24:29 AM
The second is switching Fyfe into my midfield for Kennedy from GWS and bringing Scott Selwood into my Midfield. Would love some thoughts on this.
+1 Get on the Selwood Train because its leaving Bloody Fast!

Benloz

Fyfe --> Tippett (GWS next week!)
Jude Bolton --> S.Selwood

Done.

crabapples

Quote from: Benloz on April 16, 2012, 08:36:46 AM
Fyfe --> Tippett (GWS next week!)
Jude Bolton --> S.Selwood

Done.

"i think tippets acctually the goods this year" <---- thats what everyone says every year  :P.. Beware! But seriousley if ur only putting him in because he's playing GWS next week just remember its only 1 week of the remaining 19!

thewizz

Thinking Coniglio -> NRoo, then Fyfe -> Barlow/Hayes. Sound ok?

jamesalex

Would love to get a midfielder in for Fyfe, but i'm just not confident starting with 3 forward rookies. Anyone else feel this way?

b3no

an option some people could think about is hold onto Fyfe this round, then next round trade out C. Smith to Treloar, pocket whatever cash you can make, then upgrade Fyfe to Pendlbury as hes going to drop quite abit, this still keeps your FWD, MID link.

jamesalex

Who will you get for Fyfe?

The poll contains 7 likely trade options from the forward line, but if there is someone else i missed out on just vote for "a different forward" and comment who if you can.

There is also the posibility of selecting a midfielder, by moving Fyfe into the mids. While that could be a popular option for those who have a premium mid/forward DPP in their Midfield; those who only have a rookie mid/forward DPP in their Midfield would have to then start 3 forward rookies, of which I certainly would'nt be confident of doing.

Cheers.

shuester

I know Ive asked this question in the past and 1000's of other people have asked who to trade Fyfe to but I don't think anyone has considered this guy, Kurt Tippett. I was just looking at the options I have and I saw Tippett at the top of the list.

Against the Suns: 150 (Expect that)
Against the Dogs: 77
Against the Hawks: 128 (Believe it or not)

Yeah I was very surprised he scored 128 against Hawthorn Yesturday and he was tipped for a big year. Adelaide also has an easy run this season like WCE last season but instead the crows play the GCS and GWS twice.
Adelaide are a much better side this year and the ball will come much more to the forward line this season and a game against GWS this week could see him get another 150.
Was very close to getting Whitecross but now I think Tippett's the way to go.
Oh and only 7.37% of teams have him, not a real smokey but close enough.

reesbr