The Nathan Fyfe Thread

Started by Slammer, April 14, 2012, 07:26:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who to come in for fyfe? (please no hate, i know there are many fyfe polls but please vote)

n.reiwoldt
17 (12.5%)
Sidebottom
28 (20.6%)
Cloke
7 (5.1%)
Chapman
4 (2.9%)
Blair
3 (2.2%)
Cyril
1 (0.7%)
Pav
5 (3.7%)
Whitecross
13 (9.6%)
Cornes
4 (2.9%)
Tippett
11 (8.1%)
selwood (would require ledger-->treloar)
10 (7.4%)
ward (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
hayes (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
barlow (would require ledger-->treloar)
8 (5.9%)
masten (would require ledger-->treloar)
3 (2.2%)
Montagna (would require ledger-->treloar)
0 (0%)
Ziebell (would require ledger-->treloar)
7 (5.1%)
carazzo (would require moving smedts forward)
6 (4.4%)
birchall (would require moving smedts forward)
2 (1.5%)
bock (would require moving smedts forward)
4 (2.9%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Noz

Quote from: ando_10 on April 15, 2012, 01:35:35 PM
yeah i know this isnt the section for it but:

backs: goddard, deledio, adcock, dempsey, lake , bugg, morris
emg: smedts ellis

mids: ablett, pendles, boyd, brad ebert, magner, coniglio
emg: sheil, pfeiffer

rucks: mumford, giles
emg: redden, stephenson

forwards: franklin, goodes, fyfe, sidebottom,martin, porps, kennedy
emg: dickson, d.smith

so im a little unsure what to do now a few concerns.

a bit of advice would be tops :D
Swap Fyfe to another forward premium, Dickson and Smith haven't impressed yet and not liking the thought of starting one of them.

HotTiges

waiting on the news but if its surgery its boomer for mine

Bennyy

If he has gotta go Ill be moving him to a mid premo, but you probably dont have the ability to as leaves your forward bench a bit thin if something happens

MajorLazer

Quote from: HotTiges on April 15, 2012, 08:27:41 PM
waiting on the news but if its surgery its boomer for mine
Damn right. Especially after tonights performance as well.

Ringo

Quote from: MajorLazer on April 15, 2012, 08:41:10 PM
Quote from: HotTiges on April 15, 2012, 08:27:41 PM
waiting on the news but if its surgery its boomer for mine
Damn right. Especially after tonights performance as well.
+2 Boomer in Fyfe out if surgery required,

HotTiges

good sticky thread too.. should help everyone

enzedder

Waiting...if bad...N Roo for me...3 good 100s

The Bomber

i know this is going to sound harsh and im gonna get hate from most people, but for an amazing game, left alone the whole match, racking up 38 disposals with a goal, he only scored 106 SC...whats with that...

personally if you can i reckon a underpriced prem middy is the way to go...IF YOU CAN...

HotTiges

Quote from: The Bomber on April 15, 2012, 08:58:54 PM
i know this is going to sound harsh and im gonna get hate from most people, but for an amazing game, left alone the whole match, racking up 38 disposals with a goal, he only scored 106 SC...whats with that...

personally if you can i reckon a underpriced prem middy is the way to go...IF YOU CAN...

Consistency from Boomer is pretty good for his price.. Sidealps is my other option

crabapples

Boomer 19 kicks 19 handballs 0 tackles 3 marks 4 clangers  %68 effectivness compared to daniel wells %90 who scored 139


Scalabrine

I am thinking Sidebottom, been in good form and will give me some spare cash also :)

oldshepp

Hayes or Barlow in the mids?

They will be my M5

Ringo

Quote from: oldshepp on April 15, 2012, 10:06:18 PM
Hayes or Barlow in the mids?

They will be my M5
I am also looking at Ziebell as an alternative at around the same price.

MajorLazer

The fact that Bastinac and JZ also kicked 4 each and Wells had a better efficiency rate meant that Boomer's score was always going to be lower than what was "deserved" for the game he had.

But right now it's gonna be Fyfe to Boomer for my team.

HotTiges

Quote from: MajorLazer on April 15, 2012, 10:23:00 PM
The fact that Bastinac and JZ also kicked 4 each and Wells had a better efficiency rate meant that Boomer's score was always going to be lower than what was "deserved" for the game he had.

But right now it's gonna be Fyfe to Boomer for my team.

+ 1 thinking long term